Flaw in ebay bidding software?

Techie333

Platinum Member
Jan 20, 2001
2,368
0
0
WTF!?!? I bid $40.00 on an item and the winning bidder bought the item for $40 and it wasn't me! I don't know how this happened! I also have an email confirmation saying that my maximum bid was $40.00 and the winning bid was $40.00 and I didn't win the auction. How is this possible? Is this a flaw in ebay software?
 

AnyMal

Lifer
Nov 21, 2001
15,780
0
76
Originally posted by: Techie333
WTF!?!? I bid $40.00 on an item and the winning bidder bought the item for $40 and it wasn't me! I don't know how this happened! I also have an email confirmation saying that my maximum bid was $40.00 and the winning bid was $40.00 and I didn't win the auction. How is this possible? Is this a flaw in ebay software?

Have you looked at the bidding history? It should have timestamps up to the seconds. Looks like someone put a bid before you did.
 

mobobuff

Lifer
Apr 5, 2004
11,099
1
81
Hmm... weird.

Buy It Now > *

I just got an IBM R40 off eBay today for $825 BIN. P4 2.4, Radeon 7500 36mb, 40G hard drive, CD-RW/DVD combo, 512MB RAM (will add more), docking station, carrying bag, external floppy... mmmm. T'was a good score.
 

Steve

Lifer
May 2, 2004
15,946
11
81
No, this is normal and exactly how eBay works. The winner is the person with the highest maximum bid. Your max bid was $40, his was more, therefore he won and only had to pay the price of the next highest bid. You will never know through eBay what his maximum bid was.


I win my auctions by placing a maximum bid that is outrageously high, so even if somebody tries to snipe they come nowhere near my highest bid.
 

Yossarian

Lifer
Dec 26, 2000
18,010
1
81
Originally posted by: sm8000
No, this is normal and exactly how eBay works. The winner is the person with the highest maximum bid. Your max bid was $40, his was more, therefore he won and only had to pay the price of the next highest bid. You will never know through eBay what his maximum bid was.


I win my auctions by placing a maximum bid that is outrageously high, so even if somebody tries to snipe they come nowhere near my highest bid.

you are about as wrong as it is possible for a human being to be.
 

tfinch2

Lifer
Feb 3, 2004
22,114
1
0
Originally posted by: sm8000
No, this is normal and exactly how eBay works. The winner is the person with the highest maximum bid. Your max bid was $40, his was more, therefore he won and only had to pay the price of the next highest bid. You will never know through eBay what his maximum bid was.


I win my auctions by placing a maximum bid that is outrageously high, so even if somebody tries to snipe they come nowhere near my highest bid.

what's your ebay user name? i wanna run the price up on you... :evil:
 

icejunkie

Platinum Member
Oct 2, 2004
2,326
0
0
Originally posted by: Yossarian
Originally posted by: sm8000
No, this is normal and exactly how eBay works. The winner is the person with the highest maximum bid. Your max bid was $40, his was more, therefore he won and only had to pay the price of the next highest bid. You will never know through eBay what his maximum bid was.


I win my auctions by placing a maximum bid that is outrageously high, so even if somebody tries to snipe they come nowhere near my highest bid.

you are about as wrong as it is possible for a human being to be.

:laugh:
 

Techie333

Platinum Member
Jan 20, 2001
2,368
0
0
Originally posted by: sm8000
No, this is normal and exactly how eBay works. The winner is the person with the highest maximum bid. Your max bid was $40, his was more, therefore he won and only had to pay the price of the next highest bid. You will never know through eBay what his maximum bid was.


I win my auctions by placing a maximum bid that is outrageously high, so even if somebody tries to snipe they come nowhere near my highest bid.
hahahaha...ummm...i don't think i will be doing that because I don't want to pay $100 for a $40 item.
 

KarenMarie

Elite Member
Sep 20, 2003
14,372
6
81
post a link to the auction .... then there is a better chance that i can explain what happened.
 

Steve

Lifer
May 2, 2004
15,946
11
81
That's the whole POINT! You don't pay $100 - unless somebody runs the bidding up that high. You basically pay the next highest bid, maybe plus the minimum increment (if any).
 

Savarak

Platinum Member
Oct 27, 2001
2,718
1
81
so you put your max at 1,000 for a 50 dollar item, some screwball with your same idea, tries to bid with a max of 500... he gasps and leaves... you're screwed.
 

Steve

Lifer
May 2, 2004
15,946
11
81
You just gotta be smart about it, that's all ;) Whenever it's "backfired" on me, it's only been to a small degree, and nothing my bank account couldn't handle.
 

Yossarian

Lifer
Dec 26, 2000
18,010
1
81
Originally posted by: sm8000
You just gotta be smart about it, that's all ;) Whenever it's "backfired" on me, it's only been to a small degree, and nothing my bank account couldn't handle.

being smart and doing what you're doing are mutually exclusive
 

tami

Lifer
Nov 14, 2004
11,588
3
81
people cannot have the same bid UNLESS the seller is selling multiple items. the highest bidders naturally win. HOWEVER, if there is a tie for the highest bidders for the LAST available item, then it goes first come, first serve. simple.

in english: say a seller was trying to sell 10 identical PSPs. of course, buyers are only going to buy one (and i'm using this illustration for simplicity's sake). the top 9 bids were between $230 and $260. all 9 get the PSP.

now let's say there was a next highest bid by TWO bidders, a 10th and 11th, for $225. the 10th and 11th bidder are tied to possibly win the auction, but only the 10th bidder will get the item because the 10th bidder bid first.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
You were pretty close sm8000, exept that you pay the next highest bid PLUS one bid increment. You don't pay what the next highest bidder bid.
 

Steve

Lifer
May 2, 2004
15,946
11
81
Originally posted by: mugs
You were pretty close sm8000, exept that you pay the next highest bid PLUS one bid increment. You don't pay what the next highest bidder bid.

I know, I almost corrected myself in a later post.

tami - Thank you for at least speaking with reason. Your sentence "people cannot have the same bid UNLESS the seller is selling multiple items" - I know about this as I have participated in those types of auctions. When it's a single item, what mugs said below you is correct. And I believe you about first come, first serve.

So, where exactly did I go wrong?
 

Mo0o

Lifer
Jul 31, 2001
24,227
3
76
Originally posted by: sm8000
Originally posted by: mugs
You were pretty close sm8000, exept that you pay the next highest bid PLUS one bid increment. You don't pay what the next highest bidder bid.

I know, I almost corrected myself in a later post.

tami - Thank you for at least speaking with reason. Your sentence "people cannot have the same bid UNLESS the seller is selling multiple items" - I know about this as I have participated in those types of auctions. When it's a single item, what mugs said below you is correct. And I believe you about first come, first serve.

So, where exactly did I go wrong?

Why dont you proxy the maximum you are willing to spend as opposed to some outrageously high number? That way you dont take the risk of paying past what you are willing to spend. or is that too logical
 

Steve

Lifer
May 2, 2004
15,946
11
81
I've never known much about it, learned how proxy works or tried it out. I'd be willing to try it sometime down the road. I've had to stop my eBay activities for a while because I need to start hanging onto my money. I'm owed about $1500 in loans to my brother and sister.
 

MaxFusion16

Golden Member
Dec 21, 2001
1,512
1
0
your max bids were both $40, however he bid first, so you must up the bid to over $40, like $40.50 or $41 to win the auction.

this is normal, it's how ebay works.