• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Five Guys hype

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Kaido said:
Five Guys: The Cajun fries are good, meh on the rest. I can't eat gluten, so no bun for me, so my experience has been a lettuce-wrapped burger. The burgers are extremely bland. I also can't do dairy, so no cheese, so I'd imagine the bun & cheese are what makes the burgers good, since all of my friends love eating there but I could pass. BurgerFi has WAY better food, but they aren't very widespread yet.
Click to expand...

LOL, sorry that's pretty funny.

Hey guys, the food sucks, but I couldn't eat any of it!
 
darkswordsman17 said:
My experience is very different. The time I had Smashburger it was the worst burger, bar none, that I've had. Well not quite, there was one time ordered a burger at a mom and pop restaurant and there was blood all over the plate and bun because they barely cooked the damn thing (and then the idiots send it back out on the same plate and blood soaked bun after cooking it).
Click to expand...

That's a bummer, that's the first bad review of Smashburger I've read. Although it sounds more like a poor service issue than a food quality issue. I've never been to one, but I copy their technique for doing the majority of my burgers (3-minute burger-ball smash-fried at a high-temp in a cast-iron pan).

Part of my problem with eating burgers out is that I can make great ones at home. There are some places I do like eating burgers out at (BurgerFi, and an expanding CT/Mass chain called Plan B), but it only takes a few minutes to fire up a burger & get awesome results myself, so it's not something I get when I eat out very much.
 
LikeLinus said:
LOL, sorry that's pretty funny.

Hey guys, the food sucks, but I couldn't eat any of it!
Click to expand...

Well, yes and no. The core idea of Five Guys is their burger. Their burger has no flavor; that's the issue. I've been to 3 or 4 of the different Five Guys locations in my travels around Connecticut, several times each when I need a quick lunch, so it's been consistent across their stores. Most places sell a "low carb" burger, which is wrapped in lettuce, so it isn't an unusual thing to eat a gluten-free burger:

http://www.poormansatkins.com/blog/five-guys-burgers-lettuce-wrapped-burger-review

In their case, I think their bun is what makes the flavor come together, versus a place like BurgerFi (same exact concept, down to the peanut oil), which actually has a great-tasting burger patty regardless of not using a bun.
 
KnightBreed said:
I am a big fan of Five Guys and Chipotle. Thankfully I don't have an irrational desire to hate everything people love.
Click to expand...

Based off some people liking something anything could be considered something people love. Both Five Guys and Chipotle pretty much have universal 3 - 3 1/2 star ratings on Yelp. With 10 of thousands of reviews for each. I wouldn't exactly call 3 1/2 stars a place people love.
 
If anyone is from Memphis or has had a Hughey's burger, those are damn good. I tried one last week and supposedly they are well known for their burgers and have a seasoning sold in stores
 
Captante said:
Calling 5 Guys crap is a bit much.

Calling them VERY over-rated on the other hand is right on target,
Click to expand...

They're a mass market, greasy spoon type burger at best.

I'm a burger connoisseur too, but 5 Guys is just alright. I regretted ordering a "regular" order of fries though, would have been fine with an extra small order.
 
its a fast food burger ffs wtf do you expect? never heard anyone "hype" five guys before. it's good for what it is though, and better than the other normal national chain places.
 
mmntech said:
Five Guys isn't crap, but it sells bland fried burgers. Barely a step up from McDonald's IMO. Was quite disappointed after all the praise ATOT gave it. There's better burger joints out there. Even run of the mill Harvey's is better, and cheaper too. They flame grill theirs.
Click to expand...

flame grilled means nothing. some of the best burgers are cooked on a flat-top r.e. shake shack.
 
Kaido said:
Well, yes and no. The core idea of Five Guys is their burger. Their burger has no flavor; that's the issue. I've been to 3 or 4 of the different Five Guys locations in my travels around Connecticut, several times each when I need a quick lunch, so it's been consistent across their stores. Most places sell a "low carb" burger, which is wrapped in lettuce, so it isn't an unusual thing to eat a gluten-free burger:

http://www.poormansatkins.com/blog/five-guys-burgers-lettuce-wrapped-burger-review

In their case, I think their bun is what makes the flavor come together, versus a place like BurgerFi (same exact concept, down to the peanut oil), which actually has a great-tasting burger patty regardless of not using a bun.
Click to expand...

I was teasing you, but honestly it's the ingredients that make it taste good. We get them "all the way" and they are pretty darn good. All of my co-workers like them and I've never really heard anything bad. They may be a tad greasy though. They give you a ton of fries and we usually share. Cajun is the way to go..
 
QueBert said:
Based off some people liking something anything could be considered something people love. Both Five Guys and Chipotle pretty much have universal 3 - 3 1/2 star ratings on Yelp. With 10 of thousands of reviews for each. I wouldn't exactly call 3 1/2 stars a place people love.
Click to expand...

Their expansion and sales say otherwise. I couldn't give a shit about their yelp reviews. Every Chipotle I've ever been to is busy with a line to the door. If people don't love Chipotle they sure have a funny way of showing it. I don't eat at Five Guys that often but there is a lot more competition for cheap burgers.
 
Five Guys rocks, and OP has the taste buds of a small igneous stone. Just saying.
 
For what they are I think Five Guys is pretty good. It is a fast food joint. For the money I would eat Five Guys burgers over most other fast food chain restaurants.

If anybody is expecting a great burger from a fast food joint. I dont know what to tell them.
 
Went there once. Took four months to get my order. Burger was pretty good, but about what I could get from Dairy Queen faster and cheaper. Fries were bland (even with Cajun seasoning), burnt, and expensive. I've never been back.
 
Captante said:
Calling 5 Guys crap is a bit much.

Calling them VERY over-rated on the other hand is right on target,
Click to expand...

i approve of this post.

5 guys is good, but it's nothing to write home about.

here in SoCal there's a place called Father's Office. they're very pretentious about their burgers - you can only order the burger, with no modifications. their burgers are good, but the best i've ever had were made by my brother with a little bit of rub and 1 slice of cheese. seriously, those burgers were to die for.
 
mmntech said:
Five Guys isn't crap, but it sells bland fried burgers. Barely a step up from McDonald's IMO. Was quite disappointed after all the praise ATOT gave it. There's better burger joints out there. Even run of the mill Harvey's is better, and cheaper too. They flame grill theirs.
Click to expand...

Fried? Uh, there's this thing called a grill that you can see them using behind the checkout counter...

You're welcome not to like them, but "barely a step up from McDonalds" is simply not true. They're the Panera Bread of burger joints. It's nothing that'll blow your mind but it's still tasty as hell.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top