Firewire or USB2 external hard drive?

Jim Bancroft

Senior member
Nov 9, 2004
212
2
81
Does it matter whether I get a Firewire or USB external hard drive, all other things being equal? One has a throughput of 480 MB/s, the other 400 MB, but as I understand it the PCI bus only can sustain 133 MB/s, so it's somewhat moot.....or am I leaving something out of the equation?
 

WackyDan

Diamond Member
Jan 26, 2004
4,794
68
91
Depends on the size and number of files you'll be transferring at one time. I run both USB 2 and Firewore drives. I notice the firewire is a bit faster over-all, but not incredibly faster.
 

biostud

Lifer
Feb 27, 2003
20,251
7,382
136
Firewire is faster than USB2.0 even though the theoretical numbers says the opposite. I would recommend buying a box with both USB2.0 and firewire so you can plug it to all computers.
BTW the USB2.0 and firewire is 480Mbit/s and 400Mbit/s so it is 60-50Mb/s as a maximum.
 

LED

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,127
0
0
Originally posted by: biostud
Firewire is faster than USB2.0 even though the theoretical numbers says the opposite. I would recommend buying a box with both USB2.0 and firewire so you can plug it to all computers.
BTW the USB2.0 and firewire is 480Mbit/s and 400Mbit/s so it is 60-50Mb/s as a maximum.

Exactly and if possible I would even go with Firewire800 as that is as fast as running ATA
 

Pr0metheus

Junior Member
Dec 26, 2004
14
0
0
Id say the same. I have a firewire port on my computer but I dont use it because I dont have anything that needs it.
 

Comp625

Golden Member
Aug 25, 2000
1,216
0
0
How is the CPU Utilization when comparing an internal HDD vs external USB HDD vs external Firewire HDD? Obviously CPU Util. is low w/ the internal but I'm curious as to how the external counterparts fare in that department.
 

LED

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,127
0
0
Comp625...if you look closely at my benches, you can see there is little differences {3%} between the 2. Although this is in regards to Firewire 800 the same holds true for Firewire400 and USB Hi-Speed unless the Square is taxed with many other devices going on at the same time...because many USB devices are CPU dependant whereas Firewire is not (doesn't even need 1 PC to work)...That in itself should justify to anyone acquiring a case to get @ least both protocols ;)
 

Insomniak

Banned
Sep 11, 2003
4,836
0
0
My WD 80GB External HDD that should be arriving Via Fedex in about an hour has both, so I'm set. :)
 

Hikari

Senior member
Jan 8, 2002
530
0
0
I'd just get an enclosure with both (personally, I've been looking for a dual enclosure for ages. lol). Make sure it has an Oxford 911 or 922 chipset if you get one, though. It is the better of the firewire chipsets.

Firewire is slightly faster even though the raw speed is higher on usb2. The main reason I want a dual is my home PC has a firewire port, and my work one has USB2.
 

corkyg

Elite Member | Peripherals
Super Moderator
Mar 4, 2000
27,370
240
106
I have both Firewire A and USB 2 enclosures - Firewire does transfer actual data faster - and even better is Firewire B (800 vs 400) - there are no current USB 2 plans beyond 480 that I am aware of. 800 is here now.

In actual usage, Firewire is a bit more reliable than USB.
 

maxcom

Diamond Member
Dec 1, 2000
7,650
1
0
Originally posted by: Hikari
I'd just get an enclosure with both (personally, I've been looking for a dual enclosure for ages. lol). Make sure it has an Oxford 911 or 922 chipset if you get one, though. It is the better of the firewire chipsets.

Firewire is slightly faster even though the raw speed is higher on usb2. The main reason I want a dual is my home PC has a firewire port, and my work one has USB2.

looking for the same
 

LED

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,127
0
0
This one has all 3 protocols although I bough mines from Here as the TI chipset is important to me but that Rosewill may have it...
 

tormine

Junior Member
Jan 15, 2005
1
0
0
which one is the TI chipset.. cant find it, the site is poorly designed.
I need one as well because of my FS2.
Thanks
 

Bassyhead

Diamond Member
Nov 19, 2001
4,545
0
0
Originally posted by: Jim Bancroft
Does it matter whether I get a Firewire or USB external hard drive, all other things being equal? One has a throughput of 480 MB/s, the other 400 MB, but as I understand it the PCI bus only can sustain 133 MB/s, so it's somewhat moot.....or am I leaving something out of the equation?

One thing to keep in mind is that both USB and Firewire speed ratings are in mbit/sec, not MB/sec. The peak transfer that USB 2.0 can do is somewhere around 40-45MB/sec after including overhead. It seems to me that the manufacturer of the external enclosure/hard drive is going to make a bigger difference than whether you use USB or Firewire. All things equal, Firewire will run a little bit faster because it keeps its peak speeds sustained for longer than USB does.
 

intogamer

Lifer
Dec 5, 2004
19,219
1
76
Firewire are for camcorders. I threw my firewire card away. Get USB 2 it can work with older comps with usb1.1.