Well, for what it's worth, all your players are rated 90 and above for Starter % except for your RF, so going by that, you have an above average team. You have a lot of guys that have put together good seasons, but none of your guys has proven to be truly consistent over the years. Some may be putting together that resume (ie Morneau, Holliday), but if they had an off year, it wouldn't really surprise me.
Your pitching looks a little suspect, but I don't know what stats have weight, so I can't really say for sure.
Your team does lack "star power," but you've got some guys that can produce.