ok, yeah. not the worst movie I've seen recently (Spiderman 2, cough, cough).
they had a good premise, but the storyline just didn't make sense. the ending was complete horseshit and anti-climatic imho. i wish they would stop trying to make a movie with a full backstory. it's not all that interesting. reboot it and start at the end of the backstory and if necessary do flashbacks.
this movie just felt more, i don't know the word, "organic" than the past movies. had they made the cast a bit more older and accomplished and tweaked the storyline, I think this could have evolved into a decent FF4 movie.
so i give it a meh out of 10. meh meaning 4 and 1/2 stars.