Fan outflow on case top - worthwhile, or not?

pspada

Platinum Member
Dec 23, 2002
2,503
0
0
I'm considering moving to a case that is virtually identical to the one I have now, but with a fan outflow on the top. What do you think, is it worth the effort of the move?
 

chocoruacal

Golden Member
Nov 12, 2002
1,197
0
0
Originally posted by: pspada
I'm considering moving to a case that is virtually identical to the one I have now, but with a fan outflow on the top. What do you think, is it worth the effort of the move?

No. Just one more thing to make noise. You shouldn't need more than one exhuast fan in the back.
 

beatle

Diamond Member
Apr 2, 2001
5,661
5
81
I wouldn't move to the new case just for that reason. My case has a fan @ the top and it does a good job of pulling stagnant hot air out of the case (exhaust is warm) but I could probably live without it, especially in the winter.
 

pspada

Platinum Member
Dec 23, 2002
2,503
0
0
All good points, but I might get the case anyway, and test it before further considering moving my system into it. I go through cases like water anyway, so I end up not liking it, I can just sell it to someone else.
 

THUGSROOK

Elite Member
Feb 3, 2001
11,847
0
0
a top blowhole exaust is the most effective fan in you case.

if you can only have 1 fan in your case, the blowhole should be it.

:)
 

ToxicWaste

Member
Dec 6, 2003
115
0
0
In my case, the power supply sits at the very top of the case, there might be a quarter inch of gap. So, the PS fan seems to do a good job of pulling the hot air away from the top of the case. In fact, the top of my case usually feels cool to the touch. But, if your PSU is mounted lower in the case (more likely, the case is just taller than mine...) and not pulling the air out of the top, than the blow hole can be a great idea. So, when you touch the top of your case with your hand, is it warm or cool?
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
its nice as it forces an air path past the drives, and well heat should go back and up through the case. with many cases theres a dead zone in the front top area.

noise isn't a biggy if you ues low rpm.

course some cases like the big antec/chieftecs are so well ventilated for most users its unecessary. but for cramped or older cases, adding a blowhole aiint'bad. esp those pos mini towers witht the sideways mount psus that block normal cpu air flow.

make sure u have pc located where sh*t can't spill in obviously.

 

beaconengr

Junior Member
Nov 25, 2003
17
0
0
The fan on top is actually not a great idea if you have other fans on th back of the case in exhaust mode. Yes, heat rises on it own, but not when it is being pulled to the back of the case. If you try to exhaust from both the rear of the case and the top, then you will end up with dead zones of no airflow inside the case. If your case has exhaust fans in the rear of the case, then all other fans should be intake. All mechanical engineers on my staff agree with this setup.
 

pspada

Platinum Member
Dec 23, 2002
2,503
0
0
Originally posted by: beaconengr
The fan on top is actually not a great idea if you have other fans on th back of the case in exhaust mode. Yes, heat rises on it own, but not when it is being pulled to the back of the case. If you try to exhaust from both the rear of the case and the top, then you will end up with dead zones of no airflow inside the case. If your case has exhaust fans in the rear of the case, then all other fans should be intake. All mechanical engineers on my staff agree with this setup.

So, the mechanical engineers on your staff have never heard of physics? As in hot air rising? I'd hesitate to mount a blowhole fan as an intake, that's for sure. Maybe changing the rear fans to intakes instead?

 

beaconengr

Junior Member
Nov 25, 2003
17
0
0
My post clearly says that hot air rises. However, it cannot rise when it is being physically pulled in another direction. And it has nothing to do with physics. Using the top fan for an exhaust fan would work well if it had the capacity and all other fans were set to intake. The only conflict may be the power supply fans, but they are usually not all that strong. Best setup is still exhaust to the rear, and all other fans being intake, since the power supply will be set up to exhaust.
 

KillaKilla

Senior member
Oct 22, 2003
416
0
0
Why not just cut the fan mount yourself? Assuming that there are no struts where the fan would be, I don't see why not. The cases are identical, save the fan mount, right?

Also, what an anyone says, regardless of how logical, cannot change facts. If a blowhole fan lowers your case temp the most, then it is the most effective fan.
 

KillaKilla

Senior member
Oct 22, 2003
416
0
0
Originally posted by: beatle
... especially in the winter.

Which has me thinking. If I get a de-hydrator couldn't I suck cold chicago winter air from outside into my case? After all, pushing 35* air through a HSF should cool a CPU/case better than 70* air, right?

 

pspada

Platinum Member
Dec 23, 2002
2,503
0
0
I'm in San Diego....I'd have to mount my case inside my fridge, and there's just no room! :light: