Falling Skies, very disappointing (yet partly good)

Craig234

Lifer
May 1, 2006
38,548
350
126
Sometimes, a series can seem bad but still pull me in to watch. This was one.

It sort of felt very 'manafactured'. Like a couple industry people had decided they want to make a sci-fi series, so just make one up and go. Not a lot of heart.

But it was very good in some ways. The special effects in particular, and bits - some storylines, some characters. Acting was generally pretty good.

But an example of the artificial feel was the season was where the leader Tom told the camp 'find their rage'.

This had 'some writer came up with the idea and forced it all over the season' all over it. Episodes would have things that seemed created just to use the theme.

A pet peeve, though. Or two.

One was when they decided to start killing women off near the end, purely to try to increase the drama they added pregnancy to it, gratuitously.

First, the long going relationship with I think her name was Sarah and the Hans Solo type. She was a pretty good character but hey let's have some drama and kill her.

So, out of nowhere she and the guy started going on and on about her desire to have kids, talking about how they were now planning to do so. Minutes later, she's trapped, to motivate the conflict between the guy and Tom they create a pretty absurd dilemma where Tom has to choose not to save Sarah and gets the blame for killing her. One gratuitous use of pregnancy this way is bad. Two is terrible.

Next up soon after, time to kill off Tom's wife for no reason at all.

So, what does she tell him minutes before? She's pregnant! Increase the drama!

Then the series finale - won't spoil it here but could it have been more cliched and artificial?

There was enough good to keep me watching, but it was a bad aftertaste the whole time.

Maybe any show has 'good and bad' but the type of bad on this one was a bit grating with the types of flaws. The pain by numbers feel to it.

I guess as an analogy I think of the Monkees. You might get a song of theirs stuck in your head but you realize you don't really think it's good music.
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
65,906
14,308
146
It was never very good...and there have been a few threads about it here.

Sometimes, in spite of the cheesiness, it was fun to watch...other times, it was just fucking stupid.

The scripts and acting were almost never more than mediocre...and usually less than that.
 

Craig234

Lifer
May 1, 2006
38,548
350
126
I thought they pretty badly hacked together the ending. I guess there's only so much they could do. That's nothing new - what series doesn't?
 

lupi

Lifer
Apr 8, 2001
32,539
260
126
As I said during the original thread, it was an enjoyable watch, at least until the last half of the last season. It then took on the distinct feel of the producers being told this was their last season so wrap things up best as you could. If felt like the writers planned for at least one more season based on the pacing.
 

Craig234

Lifer
May 1, 2006
38,548
350
126
As I said during the original thread, it was an enjoyable watch, at least until the last half of the last season. It then took on the distinct feel of the producers being told this was their last season so wrap things up best as you could. If felt like the writers planned for at least one more season based on the pacing.

There are likely interviews discussing this?
 

slugg

Diamond Member
Feb 17, 2002
4,723
80
91
My fiancé and I both watched it start to finish. We thought the show was good enough to keep us busy and entertained, but not exactly a work of art. We have it the benefit of the doubt, allowed it to be cheesy, rolled our eyes at those parts, and just kept going. With that, we liked the show.

Was the ending slapped together? Absolutely. But at least it had an ending. There are so many shows I refuse to watch, simply because they just don't even have an ending. It was nice to have one.
 

Craig234

Lifer
May 1, 2006
38,548
350
126
My fiancé and I both watched it start to finish. We thought the show was good enough to keep us busy and entertained, but not exactly a work of art. We have it the benefit of the doubt, allowed it to be cheesy, rolled our eyes at those parts, and just kept going. With that, we liked the show.

Was the ending slapped together? Absolutely. But at least it had an ending. There are so many shows I refuse to watch, simply because they just don't even have an ending. It was nice to have one.

Well, a better one than Under the Dome.
 

StinkyPinky

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2002
6,956
1,268
126
Overall I liked the show. And I have to echo it was nice for a show to have an ending for once, rather than just run out of steam and get canceled on a cliffhanger.

Was it perfect? No way, but it was good popcorn entertainment. If you want a show that absolutely blew the final season look no further than Fringe. Seasons 2 to 4 of that show were amazing, really good quality TV. And then season 5 sucked so badly it soured my perception of the show.