• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

External HDD, suggestions?

mentalcrisis00

Senior member
Feb 18, 2006
522
0
0
Hey all

I've been in the market for an external HDD for awhile. I just got into video editing and my 30GB Ipod just isn't cutting it anymore. I was looking into getting a 500GB HDD and putting it into an external enclosure but they are all so bulky and I'm going on a trip to Ireland this June. I'm already carrying a Sony Camcorder with charger, a Nikon D50 with charger, and a laptop with Charger. I would love to have a portable external HDD that I can just plug one cable in for power and data transfer.

I've been looking at the 2.5 inch form factor drives because they're small and portable. I am getting a Macally 2.5 enclosure because it's like the only one that has USB and Firewire, I like firewire because it will power the drive on any system and I will be using this on MAC and PC. I'm looking at drives and I can get up to 120GB-160GB with the cash I have but I'm wondering if having an IDE interface would be slower than a SATA? Would I notice a difference with data transfer and write speeds?

Should I just get a desktop sized sata drive and deal with the bulk? It would give me more storage at a lower price.

Lastly what should I be formating these drives as to work on both MAC and PC? My school has MACs which I do all my video editing on but then I like to back it up on my Desktop that has a 1TB drive. I tried NTSF, works on PC but not on MAC, and then I tried formating the drive on MAC but now it doesn't work on my PC.

Any suggestions are welcome

-Ray