<< The valentine 1 is a very poor radar dector. >>
Yea, whatever. I'm not about to part with my V1...it has proven time and again to be a reliable defense against radar.
This review on radartest.com is biased and a joke. They complain about the controls, the loudness and the information provided by the unit. Too many functions? The V1 is so easy to use. Turn the dial for volume, turn the second dial for mute volume. Push the dial to change modes. Wow, that's freakin' hard.
Audio level too low? They must have had cotton in their ears. The V1 is by far the loudest detector I've ever used. I don't even turn the volume past half-way. They say "the Passport not only displays band ID but also the relative signal strength of each, helping to prioritize the threat." Great, so you have to watch it scroll through each one on the 1-line display. Know how the V1 prioritizes the threat? The location of the strongest radar source is indicated by the blinking arrow on the directional arrow display (a feature EXCLUSIVE to V1) and its wavelength is indicated by the blinking LED. Fantastic. No thought, just glance and BAM, you know where the radar is. I could care less what radartest.com thinks, the V1's information interface is unsurpassed.
Complain, complain, complain. "No auto mute." Why would you want one? I don't want to have the thing mute a real radar source that I forgot about. If I know the source is a bogey then I'll mute it myself. "No user-programmable features." Nope, it's a surveilance device, not a stereo receiver. "No text display". A dubious feature; you're driving, not reading little messages scrolling across the detector. "No Voice alerts." What? Chirps aren't modern enough? "No selectable band defeat." WHY would I want to turn off a radar band? I want protection of all bands all the time. "No tutorial mode." Doesn't need it because it is so intuitive to use. "Lights are too bright at night." If you are bothered by them, get the remote display unit.
They admitted the V1 is tops for unfiltered X band and very close to the top for city X band and K band. They say the V1 trailed the others by a "staggering" 17000 feet (3.2 miles) on Ka band, calling it a "critical shortcoming". But wait a minute. The 8500 picked up the Ka radar at 40,222 feet, which means the V1 picked it up at about 23,000 feet. Big difference? On paper, yes, but it makes no difference on the road. 23000 feet is still 4.4 miles! You could give me a warning 100 miles ahead, it means nothing more to me. Heck, as long as it goes off within a 1/2 mile of the cop with the radar, I'm happy. Think about it. It's also interesting how the V1 wins the highway curve battle, a critical test because cops don't hide in straightaways, they hide around curves.
Test scores: BEL 980 - 94, Escort 8500 - 97, V1 - 77. But if you look at the breakdown, several of these categories are subjective and subject to bias and personal preference. From a practical perspective, the V1 belongs near the top of the rankings. It's been considered number one enough times in the past that it has become Goliath and this test is populism and journalism mixed to poor recourse. Some are also upset with the inaccessibility of the price and think the V1 is crap because it is out of their price range. I paid $399 for my V1 4 years ago and looking at eBay, it would fetch in the low-$300s on resale. Of course, I'm not going to sell it, but proves the point of its long-term value.
If I was new to the detector market, I would give a close look at the Escort 8500 but probably would find the V1's exclusive directional display to be a feature not to be missed. It has saved my butt many times.