DVD decision time (Pioneer DVD105-16x/40x slot loading???)

dalfollo

Senior member
Jan 10, 2001
452
0
0
I am going to get a DVD/CDROM unit instead of just a CDROM
for a PC i am building based on an ABIT KT&RAID/AMD 1.0.
I expect to pay <150 for a decent unit...it doen't have to
be the best, but i don't want to find that it's not good
enough....i don't know DVDs well...

I am focusing on the Pioneer 16x/40x DVD Slot Loading below***

Any reason to go tray loading instead of slot loading?

Pioneer is decent DVD right?

is it worth saving the ~25 bux for a 'slower drive' or other
name brand?

here are my choices in best to worse order:

-------------------------------------------
thortek.com $136
***Pioneer 16x/40x Black Bezel DVD Internal IDE Drive/SLOT LOADING
The DVD105 features a DVD-ROM access time of 95ms, a CD-ROM access time of 80ms, a sustained DVD transfer rate up to 21.6MB/second (16X), a sustained CD-ROM transfer rate up to 6.0MB/second (40X), a 512K cache buffer, and a one year manufacturer's warranty. The DVD105 reads single and dual layer DVD-ROM/Video disks, DVD-R, DVD-RW (DVD-RAM not supported), CD-ROM, CD-ROM XA, Audio CD, CD-R, CD-RW, Video CD, Photo CD, CD-EXTRA, HYBRID CD, and CD-Text. This drive supports Windows 2000/98/95, Windows NT 4.0/3.51, Windows 3.1, and MS-DOS 6.0 or later.
A DVD Software Decoder or Hardware Decoder, which is available for purchase seperately, is required for the operation of this product (Some Video Graphic Cards include MPEG DVD Decoders).
-----------------------------------------------
thortek.com $134
Pioneer 16x DVD/40x CD Rom Internal IDE Black Face/TRAY
Pioneer DVD-115 IDE 16X DVD-Rom/40X CD-Rom bare internal black DVD Drive. This 40-pin DVD-Rom Drive features a 100ms DVD-Rom access time, 80ms CD-Rom access time, 512K cache buffer, tray loading mechanism, it is Windows 95, 98 and 2000 compatible, front panel headphone jack, half height form factor and a 1 year manufacturer's warranty.
A DVD Software Decoder or Hardware Decoder, which is available for purchase seperately, is required for the operation of this product (Some Video Graphic Cards include MPEG DVD Decoders).
-----------------------------------------------
directron.com $119
Toshiba has once again shown their technological prowess with the SD-M1402. Quite simply, their is not a more reliable high performance drive than this one. With a 12X DVD playback and 40X on CDs, this drive sports a fast 90ms DVD access time and an 80ms CD read time. Compatible with all types of media, it includes a 128kb buffer and an Ultra DMA interface. (HH drive; requires either hardware or software DVD decoding interface). DVD-ROM Drive with black face panel. OEM <oem.html> bare drive.

Hardware or software decoder required to run the DVD drive. We suggest using ATI XPert98 8MB AGP <http://www.directron.com/vd-ati-xpt98-8a.html>, which comes with a free Video Player software that can function as a DVD decoder.
-----------------------------------------------
thortek.com $150
Toshiba 16X DVD/48X CD-Rom Black Int IDE DVD Drive TRAY
Toshiba 16X DVD/48X CD-Rom bare internal IDE DVD-Rom Drive with a black face bezel. This 16X DVD drive features a 115ms DVD access time, 95ms CD-Rom access time, 128KB cache buffer, data transfer rates up to 33MB/second, it is compatible with CD-Recordable, CD-Rewritable and DVD media, it has a tray loader and the drive has a 1 year manufacturer's warranty.
-----------------------------------------------
thortek.com $125
Asus E608 8x DVD/40x Black Internal EIDE DVD-ROM/TRAY LOADING
Asus E608 Internal ATAPI/Enhanced-IDE 8X DVD-Rom/40X CD-Rom drive with a Black Face Bezel. This drive features a 110ms DVD-Rom access time, 85ms CD-Rom access time, 256K cache buffer, high speed digital audio extraction, it supports Ultra DMA/33 transfer modes, Multi-Read function which allows it to read both CD-Recordable and CD-Rewritable media, it supports DOS 6.x, Windows 3.1x/95/98/NT, OS/2 Warp, Netware, Linux, and SCO UNIX operating systems. The DVD drive also comes included with an installation disk, manual and audio cable.
-----------------------------------------------
thortek.com $110
Afreey 10x/40x DVD Internal Black w/MPEG SFT EIDE/TRAY
Afteey 10x DVD 40x CD Rom internal IDE drive. Comes with decoder software. Retail box includes driver disk, manual, and 1 year warranty.
-----------------------------------------------

Thanks for any input...this will help me to finalize
my build plan today.
 

Noriaki

Lifer
Jun 3, 2000
13,640
1
71
Go with the Toshiba.

It's every bit as good as the Pioneer, it's also quieter and I've seen quite a few reports of complaints on the Pioneer lately.

My pioneer is starting to go and it's just over a year old...
Do a search in the hardware forum for keyword &quot;panasonic&quot; and look at my thread about the Panasonic 8x DVD...there are 4 or 5 users in there complaining of dead or dieing Pioneer drives...and I've heard more else where.

The pioneer was very good while it lasted...but it's dissapointing me lately...
 

Tonec

Golden Member
Feb 29, 2000
1,505
0
0
If you have a cdrw in your system, can't beat the clonecd and overall read compatibility of toshiba drives
 

nortexoid

Diamond Member
May 1, 2000
4,096
0
0
A Panasonic 8XDVD can be had for $80 CDN, ~$52 American....

i wouldn't get anything else, unless u desparately want a slot load. (which defnitely look cooler, are slightly quicker to load/unload)

speed is not a big deal...my 5X has 100% smooth playback, even when fastforwarding 4X...at 8X fast forward, it starts to get choppy...but who cares..u can seek by time, chapter, etc...fastforwarding at 8X is useless.
 

AmdEmAll

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2000
6,699
9
81
Yeah my Pioneer 6x is almost dead now. It pretty much wont read anything :( Im gonna get a toshiba dvd drive. Where is the best place to get one? Im looking to spend around $100. Im looking at the Toshiba 12x for $89 at directron. Should I go for that or is there a better one I should get?