I got dungeons of dredmor last night and have been thoroughly enjoying it. I consider myself an 'older' gamer having started out playing on an Apple II in the 70s, and this game reminds me of old rogue like RPGs, which it does wonderfully. The crafting mechanic is definitely something from the modern era of gaming. So far it is good, i've been playing it on my G73 laptop and it is great to find a fun game that doesn't require me to hook a gamepad or grab my mouse. For the cost of a starbucks coffee, it's a good purchase.
I like the idea of including a random skill button and the permadeath feature. Some of the descriptions and names are just hilarious.