DSL Router Recommendations

Kinadorm

Junior Member
Nov 13, 2003
2
0
0
I need to buy a DSL router and thought maybe you guys could give some good suggestions. It's just for a home LAN and wireless isn't necessary but I thought I would go ahead and get it in case I need it later. I am mainly looking for reliability and speed. So far I think I will get one of the following. Which would you guys recommend?

D-Link DI-624

SMC SMC2804WBR

Netgear WGR614

Netgear WGT624

Netgear RP614


Also, I couldn't tell a difference between the Netgear WGR614 and the WGT624. If anyone knows what the letters in the model number stand for that would help.

Thanks for any help and feel free to suggest a router thats not listed.
 

JackMDS

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 25, 1999
29,545
422
126
You are looking for Speed? No difference.

You are looking for reliabilty? Pray to you Devine of choice.

As related to Entry Level Cable/DSL Router.

Cable/DSL Routers main function is to provide Network Address Translation (NAT). It is necessary to provide NAT when you share one Internet connection so that each computer will send, and receive the Internet information that belongs to it.

By product of this NAT is simple but effective Firewall.

NAT is implemented in a way that each computer can get only the info that was requested from inside of the LAN. As a result "rouge" info. from the Internet can not get in (since it was not requested). The NAT Firewall just blocks en-mass every thing that tries to come in none requested.

So what do you do if you want a system that can answer request coming independently in?

The "Shut Gun" approach is to put one computer on the DMZ (De Militarized Zone) i.e. no military no one is protecting you. Under this setting one of your Network computers is out in front of the Firewall, thus all the ports are Opened. Be careful while being on the DMZ the computer is exposed to the Internet

Port Opening - Individual and few Ports can be open for special communication.

E.g. In a case you want to keep an ftp server, to let your friends download files.

You open the port and info can come in through this port regardless of the NAT (e.g. for ftp you open port 21).

Port Range - Most Routers let you define a range of ports to be kept open (e.g. 5000-6000).

Port Triggering - Some applications connect to the Internet by using port X expecting an answer through port Y. Port Triggering makes sure that port Y is available to receive the answer.

The way to open a port depends on the Router, and or Firewall program. Each manufacture has his own "Shticks" to go about it. Each one has his way of organizing the Menus. You have to read the Manual in order to know how to do it. The term that it is referred to could be Port Mapping, Port Opening, etc. In a Virtual Server.

List of ports that are associated with various applications can be found here:

Link to: Special Applications - Port List.


SPI is the next level of protection offered currently by the newest Cable/DSL Routers. It adds an actual examination of the Network Outbound and Inbound Packets, thus can make a content decision.

The following is an Example of the SPI help file on my Router (SMC Barricade).

Allow all to pass except those match the specified rules
Deny all to pass except those match the specified rules
You can specify 8 rules for each directions: inbound or outbound. For each rule, you can define the following:
Source IP address
Source port address
Destination IP address
Destination port address
Protocol: TCP or UDP or both.
For source or destination IP address, you can define a single IP address (4.3.2.1) or a range of IP addresses (4.3.2.1-4.3.2.254). An empty implies all IP addresses.

Each rule can be enabled or disabled individually.

----------------------------------------------------

SPI might help businesses to control their employs ?recreational? surfing,

SPI can help parents to better protect their kids.

-----------------------------------------------------

More about protection here: Basic Protection for Broadband Internet Installation.


About UPnP you can read here: Universal Plug n' Play.

 

thatsright

Diamond Member
May 1, 2001
3,004
3
81
Originally posted by: Kinadorm
I need to buy a DSL router and thought maybe you guys could give some good suggestions. It's just for a home LAN and wireless isn't necessary but I thought I would go ahead and get it in case I need it later. I am mainly looking for reliability and speed. So far I think I will get one of the following. Which would you guys recommend?

D-Link DI-624

SMC SMC2804WBR

Netgear WGR614

Netgear WGT624

Netgear RP614



Also, I couldn't tell a difference between the Netgear WGR614 and the WGT624. If anyone knows what the letters in the model number stand for that would help.

Thanks for any help and feel free to suggest a router thats not listed.

Well I am happier than a 'Pig in Feces' with my RP614. It was $40 or so back in May. Pretty easy to setup, and in the 6-Months I have had it, I have only accessed the Admin screen maybe 4 times. Not a problem since and very fast throughput and I was VERY surprised at how much bandwidth I was able to use while transferring very large files between two PC's on my network. I transfered a 300MB file, and I was averaging around 70% usage with all Cat5e (100MB) cabling.

But, of course those that are happy with what they have are always going to tout what they have and not really know what else is out there, so read a few reviews that are out there first. ONE LAST THING, whatever router you buy, upgrade the firmware first to the latest version to protect you against the latest exploits that are out there. Good luck.

And WELCOME TO THE AT FORUMS!!
 

JackMDS

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 25, 1999
29,545
422
126
Actually you might want to take a close look at the D-Link624.

The Router is rated 108MHz. It is a gimmick i.e. it is not "real" 108MHz device.

However with a compatible D-Link Client Card you can extract from this device 20%-40% more bandwidth than the others.

And BTW, if you want to compare features do not use the "Artist" summaries on vendor?s sites.

Log to the Brand's site look for the support page of the device and download the actual manual etc.