- Nov 27, 2001
- 30,383
- 912
- 126
I went to see Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness yesterday, and I hate to say this... but I think it's in the bottom tier of Marvel movies for me. Ultimately, I thought the writing and dialog were just subpar -- especially given that Spider-Man: No Way Home came right before this -- and I really didn't think that Sam Raimi's direction was anything great. Unfortunately, I can't go into too many complaints without going into what I believe are spoilers. I haven't seen all of the trailers and TV spots to know if some of this (such as the villain) has been revealed.
The Story: Basically, the story felt a bit lazy. It's about the quality that you'd expect in an origin story movie where the main focus is on the growth/change with the main character. However... that's not really what this movie is about. The story in this movie is essentially an extension of Wandavision where Wanda is trying to steal America Chavez's dimension hopping power so she can steal her kids from another universe. To be frank, I'm just not a huge fan of this storyline as a whole. I can certainly understand the motivations of Wanda as a character wanting to live the life she thinks she has been robbed of, but I'm not sure if the movie does a great job of conveying that outside of some Full House-esque shots of her with the kids. I thought the scene near the end of her confronting the kids and her other self was far more emotional and worked a lot better than anything else. Although, hopefully someone can fill me in on one thing... what did that universe's Wanda say to the MCU Wanda before she was brought back? I couldn't understand it nor could anyone that I went with.
The Direction: I wouldn't consider myself a diehard Raimi fan or anything like that, but I know how to spot a few Raimi-isms when it comes to directing. For example, his penchant for up-close face shots in times of duress. (There are some of those in here.) Now, at least based upon what I've heard in videos discussing some of his prior work, one aspect that he is fond of is off-kilter shots typically through angling (Dutch Angle, etc.). I don't know if I missed it, but outside of those close-ups, the movie seemed fairly bogstandard. There was one scene that came across as really awkward, it was when Wanda was outside Kamar Taj and talking to Doctor Strange right before attacking. She just goes on this monologue, and the shot has this weird... almost creepy framing to it. A part of me wonders if that was done on purpose to be unsettling for the viewer, because Wanda's mindset is supposed to be unsettling... or if I'm just giving Raimi too much credit for a weird decision.
One thing I did see people touch on in reviews is that there is more "gore" in this movie than pretty much any other Marvel movie. It is pretty tame levels of gore though. The vast majority of the gore involves a fight between Wanda and the Illuminati (Black Bolt, Mister Fantastic, Captain Marvel, Professor X, and Captain Carter). The most gory of this was like when Black Bolt's mouth was "removed" by Wanda and he ended up shouting and scrambling his brains inside his head. (It looked a bit like a balloon deflating.) Mister Fantastic was turned into a giant twist-n-peel candy. Captain Carter got cut in half with her shield (not visible; implied). I actually saw that this scene got posted to YouTube if you want to see it.
There is one thing that kind of bugged me, and it is a complete spoiler. This movie features the Illuminati, which was heavily hinted at in the trailer. As noted in a previous inline spoiler tag, the Illuminati includes Mordo as Sorcerer Supreme, Captain Marvel, Reed Richards, Professor X, Black Bolt, and Captain Carter. Now, I'm going to sound a bit picky about this, but I really didn't feel great about the portrayal of Reed Richards. The reason why I'm harping on this is because Marvel is likely planning on bringing back the Fantastic Four, and getting the characters right is an important aspect. I don't consider myself a Fantastic Four expert or anything close to that, but my understanding is that Reed Richards should come across as a bit of an ass. It's not that he's a mean person, but rather he has this slavish devotion to logic and his view of what's right. This Reed Richards, played by John Krasinsky, had that a little bit when talking about how they executed their Doctor Strange. However, he seemed far too nice -- and frankly, for being the "smartest man alive", really stupid -- when confronting Wanda. Also, as a complete side note... I was really hoping they'd include Namor and maybe the alternate Iron Man since both of them are supposed to be part of the Illuminati.
To be blunt, it seems like Phase 4 has been pretty bad so far. Out of the four released movies, only one of them (Spider-Man: No Way Home) was arguably well done, and the other three were (in my opinion) either bad (The Eternals) or just mediocre (Black Widow, Doctor Strange 2). I do have some hope for Thor 4, but a part of me does worry a bit because the current trailer for the movie is pulling the exact same stunt as Doctor Strange 2... not showing the villain. The movie comes out two months from now, and they aren't willing to show off Christian Bale's Gorr the God Butcher? Is it simply because they want to make it seem more like Thor's quest to find himself, which is more or less what the trailer suggests, or because it won't be very good? (To be fair, it's also a teaser and not technically a trailer.)
The Story: Basically, the story felt a bit lazy. It's about the quality that you'd expect in an origin story movie where the main focus is on the growth/change with the main character. However... that's not really what this movie is about. The story in this movie is essentially an extension of Wandavision where Wanda is trying to steal America Chavez's dimension hopping power so she can steal her kids from another universe. To be frank, I'm just not a huge fan of this storyline as a whole. I can certainly understand the motivations of Wanda as a character wanting to live the life she thinks she has been robbed of, but I'm not sure if the movie does a great job of conveying that outside of some Full House-esque shots of her with the kids. I thought the scene near the end of her confronting the kids and her other self was far more emotional and worked a lot better than anything else. Although, hopefully someone can fill me in on one thing... what did that universe's Wanda say to the MCU Wanda before she was brought back? I couldn't understand it nor could anyone that I went with.
The Direction: I wouldn't consider myself a diehard Raimi fan or anything like that, but I know how to spot a few Raimi-isms when it comes to directing. For example, his penchant for up-close face shots in times of duress. (There are some of those in here.) Now, at least based upon what I've heard in videos discussing some of his prior work, one aspect that he is fond of is off-kilter shots typically through angling (Dutch Angle, etc.). I don't know if I missed it, but outside of those close-ups, the movie seemed fairly bogstandard. There was one scene that came across as really awkward, it was when Wanda was outside Kamar Taj and talking to Doctor Strange right before attacking. She just goes on this monologue, and the shot has this weird... almost creepy framing to it. A part of me wonders if that was done on purpose to be unsettling for the viewer, because Wanda's mindset is supposed to be unsettling... or if I'm just giving Raimi too much credit for a weird decision.
One thing I did see people touch on in reviews is that there is more "gore" in this movie than pretty much any other Marvel movie. It is pretty tame levels of gore though. The vast majority of the gore involves a fight between Wanda and the Illuminati (Black Bolt, Mister Fantastic, Captain Marvel, Professor X, and Captain Carter). The most gory of this was like when Black Bolt's mouth was "removed" by Wanda and he ended up shouting and scrambling his brains inside his head. (It looked a bit like a balloon deflating.) Mister Fantastic was turned into a giant twist-n-peel candy. Captain Carter got cut in half with her shield (not visible; implied). I actually saw that this scene got posted to YouTube if you want to see it.
There is one thing that kind of bugged me, and it is a complete spoiler. This movie features the Illuminati, which was heavily hinted at in the trailer. As noted in a previous inline spoiler tag, the Illuminati includes Mordo as Sorcerer Supreme, Captain Marvel, Reed Richards, Professor X, Black Bolt, and Captain Carter. Now, I'm going to sound a bit picky about this, but I really didn't feel great about the portrayal of Reed Richards. The reason why I'm harping on this is because Marvel is likely planning on bringing back the Fantastic Four, and getting the characters right is an important aspect. I don't consider myself a Fantastic Four expert or anything close to that, but my understanding is that Reed Richards should come across as a bit of an ass. It's not that he's a mean person, but rather he has this slavish devotion to logic and his view of what's right. This Reed Richards, played by John Krasinsky, had that a little bit when talking about how they executed their Doctor Strange. However, he seemed far too nice -- and frankly, for being the "smartest man alive", really stupid -- when confronting Wanda. Also, as a complete side note... I was really hoping they'd include Namor and maybe the alternate Iron Man since both of them are supposed to be part of the Illuminati.
To be blunt, it seems like Phase 4 has been pretty bad so far. Out of the four released movies, only one of them (Spider-Man: No Way Home) was arguably well done, and the other three were (in my opinion) either bad (The Eternals) or just mediocre (Black Widow, Doctor Strange 2). I do have some hope for Thor 4, but a part of me does worry a bit because the current trailer for the movie is pulling the exact same stunt as Doctor Strange 2... not showing the villain. The movie comes out two months from now, and they aren't willing to show off Christian Bale's Gorr the God Butcher? Is it simply because they want to make it seem more like Thor's quest to find himself, which is more or less what the trailer suggests, or because it won't be very good? (To be fair, it's also a teaser and not technically a trailer.)