do you guys think this pocket infrared spectrometer will be good?

Status
Not open for further replies.

lxskllr

No Lifer
Nov 30, 2004
58,562
8,840
126
Interesting, but I don't like how it relies on outside services to work. I'd rather it did everything from the phone or computer.
 

Paperdoc

Platinum Member
Aug 17, 2006
2,412
330
126
Interesting, but I don't like how it relies on outside services to work. I'd rather it did everything from the phone or computer.

That might be nice. But consider what needs to be done. The IR spectrum must be compared to a huge database of spectra of known compounds to identify which of them is present. There will be MANY such matching compounds. Then some calculation has to be done to estimate the relative amounts of each of the identified compounds. All this is well beyond the capability of a small hand-held device, or even of a good smartphone. It makes sense to have it done at a remote site with powerful computing resources and huge database storage and search ability. If it all works as advertised, it is quite amazing that it can be done for any reasonable price.
 

lxskllr

No Lifer
Nov 30, 2004
58,562
8,840
126
That might be nice. But consider what needs to be done. The IR spectrum must be compared to a huge database of spectra of known compounds to identify which of them is present. There will be MANY such matching compounds. Then some calculation has to be done to estimate the relative amounts of each of the identified compounds. All this is well beyond the capability of a small hand-held device, or even of a good smartphone. It makes sense to have it done at a remote site with powerful computing resources and huge database storage and search ability. If it all works as advertised, it is quite amazing that it can be done for any reasonable price.

Maybe. I don't know much about it, but if I could fit a database into a few GBs, and have it take a couple minutes longer to compute on my own device, I'd rather do that.
 

brainhulk

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2007
9,376
454
126
Some say the results will be meaningless without professional interpretation. Naaaaa...ill just google it. Gimme my goddam spectrometer now

(Don't you hate it when you have to take an opposing view that contradicts your elitist self from another thread? Dammit)
 
Last edited:

Imp

Lifer
Feb 8, 2000
18,828
184
106
It's a nice idea and will be useful for smart people...

Most people probably wouldn't understand the results, but the people who do will probably start posting guides online. Then someone will make an app and dumb it down and all will be happy. Good idea for opening up information.
 

Mark R

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
8,513
16
81
Signal-to-noise ratio for this type of spectroscopy is very bad.

Proper spectrometers use lasers in the many hundreds of mW and scan times of minutes, and require light proof chambers to prevent contamination by ambient light. They also need large (inches diameter) optical components to optimise light capture, and resolution.

It seems utterly preposterous that a handheld keyring type device would produce any useful information for analysis of a pure substance, let alone a foodstuff or similar product. Any utility will likely be in answering very vague questions about things which have very strong IR characteristics (e.g. CO2 detection).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.