Do Emergency Rooms treat all Patients as Equal...

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

iliopsoas

Golden Member
Jul 14, 2001
1,844
2
0
Originally posted by: mattpegher
Originally posted by: kami333
Looks like the triage nurse did her job.

Next time, unless you are visibly bleeding from a major artery, go to urgent care instead. I work in a hospital complex and they advise us to drive 20min to urgent care instead of going to the ER if we can.

I work in both the ED and our Urgent care. If you have abdomenal pain your better off going to the ED because recent studies state that appendicitis cannot be reliably ruled out without CT scan.

Appendicitis should be a clinical diagnosis. People overuse CT scans to diagnose appendicitis.
 

Narmer

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2006
5,292
0
0
Originally posted by: 911paramedic
I walked out of that emergency, took the train to my house, got into my car, and drove to St. Luke's Hospital, across from Columbia University. I had to wait another hour just to be called upon

Sounds like the nurse was correct, you weren't the most severe patient in the ER.

She may have been right in that respect. But to not perform any tests and give me options was not what I expected in a doctor. By the way, just because I did all those things does not mean I wasn't in great pain. Driving towards Manhattan, I was praying that a cop would pull me over and put me in an ambulance.

Originally posted by: JDrake
Originally posted by: Kilgor
Sounds like you had gas, did you try farting?

QFT

I couldn't pee into the first 7 hours. Farting and sh!tting was out of the question until about 12 hours later.

Originally posted by: bonkers325
it really depends on the hospital you goto. Maimonides in brooklyn has excellent care... makes me scared to eat something out of Columbia's vending machines now. i always get snacks in between lectures! i hope i dont sh!t out my intestines from eating a snickers or something

Knowing what I know now, I wouldn't blame the candy in the vending machines, although I can't rule it out 100%.
 

iliopsoas

Golden Member
Jul 14, 2001
1,844
2
0
Originally posted by: Perknose
Originally posted by: cherrytwist
Don't talk to me about ERs. I was turned away twice while having congestive heart failure due to a bad aortic valve.

They knew I was a Marfanite, however did not perform the proper tests to determine the cause of the symptoms.

The 3rd time I was rushed to another hospital for an emergency Aortic Valve replacement, this at the ripe old age of

I considered a lawsuit, but I survived. I could have pursued it for pain and suffering but I'm not the typical American who will sue just because I can. What I wanted they couldn't give me. The 6 weeks back that I was suffering and wondering wtf was wrong with me.
Ouch! :( :|

My wife was moved too soon from the ICU after her esophagectomy. I came in that morning and they were moving her, wouldn't let me see her. I tracked down her lead doctor, and when I told him they were moving her, I saw him literally get white in the face. They kept me in some out of the way waiting room, alone, for nearly an hour. During the move, Jessie (my wife) aspirated stomach bile into both of her lungs. When they let me see her again, she was back in ICU, in a coma. She never made it back to consciousness, and 30 days later, she died. She was 42.

She deserved better.

I could have sued for some big bucks, in fact, I was urged to sue, but I did receive what I still consider some good advice. If you sue, the case can drag on for YEARS, it is not a pretty process, and the purple wound of your loss remains just that the whole damn time, opened and reopened by lawyers.

This was the goddamned Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, and her presiding surgeon was head of the department and had done more successful esophagectomies in the last 20 years than anyone in the nation. His brother is head of the same dept. at Jefferson Hospital, and his son is a prominent surgeon in the same field.

Sometimes you do all you humanly can and Fate still turns its cold icy back on you. But, rich man, poor man, that's just the way it is . . . and, with you or without you, life goes blindly, busily bumbling on. If you stand and sulk in the corner, Life does not give a good rat's ass.

You don't get to take your toys with you, and no one is exempt. In the end, ALL you really have is your personal honor, your integrity, and the true friends you have made and known along the way.

But see? THAT'S what makes this life, this ephemeral, evanescent gift, this almost "unbearable lightness of being", the unmatched treasure it is.

May you greet the morning sun, as I am about to, secure in the knowlege that Today is a good day to die.

No one can ever take from you what you would freely surrender anyway.


I'm sorry for your loss.

Wow. This occurred at Hospital of U Penn eh? That's considered one of the premiere institutions too :(
 

mattpegher

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2006
2,203
0
71
Originally posted by: iliopsoas
Originally posted by: mattpegher
Originally posted by: kami333
Looks like the triage nurse did her job.

Next time, unless you are visibly bleeding from a major artery, go to urgent care instead. I work in a hospital complex and they advise us to drive 20min to urgent care instead of going to the ER if we can.

I work in both the ED and our Urgent care. If you have abdomenal pain your better off going to the ED because recent studies state that appendicitis cannot be reliably ruled out without CT scan.

Appendicitis should be a clinical diagnosis. People overuse CT scans to diagnose appendicitis.

Current literature suggest that given a physical examination suspicious for Appendicitis, a normal WBC (white blood cell count) has a poor negative predictive value (ability to rule out a disease with a negative test), thus current recommendations for CT unless the physical exam is so classic that a surgeon will take the person to the OR based solely on the physical.

But Narmer said he already had his appendix out.

 

moshquerade

No Lifer
Nov 1, 2001
61,504
12
56
i would try going to an "urgent care" facility before a hospital ER.
ER's work on if someone acts more like they are dying (or in fact is actually dying) they go to the front of the line.
 

mattpegher

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2006
2,203
0
71
Originally posted by: moshquerade
i would try going to an "urgent care" facility before a hospital ER.
ER's work on if someone acts more like they are dying (or in fact is actually dying) they go to the front of the line.

Many urgent cares are simply extensions of the ER and thus have access to CT on site, but work more on a first come first served bases, not strictly thou. Our ED uses a fast tract to speed up minor ailments which works mostly the same way. Here in NJ most Urgent Care facilities are private outpatient doctors offices and have only basic laboratory and Xray capacity and thus would refer you to the hospital ER if they felt the abdomenal pain was severe. I have been an Emergency physician for 10 years now, I have worked in innercity, trauma centers, community hospitals and Urgent cares. If the Urgent Care in his vicinity has CT capacity and is staffed by experience Emergency Physician it could have been an option.
 

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Mar 5, 2001
49,601
167
111
www.slatebrookfarm.com
I then reminded her that stomach pain is the worst anybody can have. She gets mad and says that there are other more important patients.
At which point, you immediately set off alarms in her head that you were probably there just for pain relievers. ER's have a huge chunk of their time wasted by people seeking to get meds to abuse or sell.

The Emergency medicine system is on the brink of collapse due to poor staffing, poor reimbursement, uninsured/indigent, a culture that demands that every test possible be done to rule out even the most unlikely disease, patients who don't or can't see their primary in order to prevent emergency situations

2 minutes is probably plenty of time to determine that it's not an emergency situation. "If the pain is still bothering you tomorrow, see your regular physician." I'm sure that by the time the doctor got there, you had your blood pressure taken, temperature taken, pulse, and breathing rate monitored. Just a shot in the dark, but I'll bet one of the first questions asked was "when was the last time you had a bowel movement." The doctor and nurses didn't have their eyes closed - were you sweating? Pale? By this point, virtually every acute non-life threatening illness was ruled out, with the most likely culprit being simple intestinal gas. You weren't satisfied, because you still were in pain. So, you ran off to another hospital (and, unless you were discharged from the first ER, the insurance company has the option of not paying) where I'm sure you told them about your experience at the first hospital. Realizing that you would cause them all sorts of undue grief in the form of complaints, etc. if you didn't have every possible test run, they caved in and ordered those tests.

Maybe I'm a bit callous because I know too many people who work in the ER. The major theme of all the stories I hear from them is that people don't know what "emergency" means. I remember being a patient once in one of those little rooms, separated only by a curtain from the next room. For 2 hours, I got to listen to the husband or boyfriend of the lady next door ranting about how long it was taking for her to receive treatment "don't they know that you can get severe infections from burns?" She had been burned by candle wax; it was a 1st degree burn. But, everyone watches ER and all those other shows on television which frequently portray even the mildest of symptoms as stemming from or leading to severe life threatening illnesses. You went there for an emergency. I agree that it would be nice if all physicians had a pleasant bedside manner. But, they are there to treat emergency situations. If I'm there after a car accident, with blood pouring out of my body, or for a heart attack, or a stroke, or severe fever, etc., I'll forgive them if they don't smile.
 

Perknose

Forum Director & Omnipotent Overlord
Forum Director
Oct 9, 1999
46,926
10,789
147
Originally posted by: iliopsoas
Originally posted by: Perknose
Originally posted by: cherrytwist
Don't talk to me about ERs. I was turned away twice while having congestive heart failure due to a bad aortic valve.

They knew I was a Marfanite, however did not perform the proper tests to determine the cause of the symptoms.

The 3rd time I was rushed to another hospital for an emergency Aortic Valve replacement, this at the ripe old age of

I considered a lawsuit, but I survived. I could have pursued it for pain and suffering but I'm not the typical American who will sue just because I can. What I wanted they couldn't give me. The 6 weeks back that I was suffering and wondering wtf was wrong with me.
Ouch! :( :|

My wife was moved too soon from the ICU after her esophagectomy. I came in that morning and they were moving her, wouldn't let me see her. I tracked down her lead doctor, and when I told him they were moving her, I saw him literally get white in the face. They kept me in some out of the way waiting room, alone, for nearly an hour. During the move, Jessie (my wife) aspirated stomach bile into both of her lungs. When they let me see her again, she was back in ICU, in a coma. She never made it back to consciousness, and 30 days later, she died. She was 42.

She deserved better.

I could have sued for some big bucks, in fact, I was urged to sue, but I did receive what I still consider some good advice. If you sue, the case can drag on for YEARS, it is not a pretty process, and the purple wound of your loss remains just that the whole damn time, opened and reopened by lawyers.

This was the goddamned Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, and her presiding surgeon was head of the department and had done more successful esophagectomies in the last 20 years than anyone in the nation. His brother is head of the same dept. at Jefferson Hospital, and his son is a prominent surgeon in the same field.

Sometimes you do all you humanly can and Fate still turns its cold icy back on you. But, rich man, poor man, that's just the way it is . . . and, with you or without you, life goes blindly, busily bumbling on. If you stand and sulk in the corner, Life does not give a good rat's ass.

You don't get to take your toys with you, and no one is exempt. In the end, ALL you really have is your personal honor, your integrity, and the true friends you have made and known along the way.

But see? THAT'S what makes this life, this ephemeral, evanescent gift, this almost "unbearable lightness of being", the unmatched treasure it is.

May you greet the morning sun, as I am about to, secure in the knowlege that Today is a good day to die.

No one can ever take from you what you would freely surrender anyway.


I'm sorry for your loss.

Wow. This occurred at Hospital of U Penn eh? That's considered one of the premiere institutions too :(
Werd. I thought I was the big man using my high levels of smartness to protect my wife ftw.

Hubris always attracts the attention of the Gods. Pride goeth before the fall.

 

JDrake

Banned
Dec 27, 2005
10,246
0
0
Originally posted by: Narmer
Originally posted by: JDrake
Originally posted by: Kilgor
Sounds like you had gas, did you try farting?

QFT

I couldn't pee into the first 7 hours. Farting and sh!tting was out of the question until about 12 hours later.

Oh be quiet, you just had some gas which made your tummy hurt, girlie man.