- Apr 23, 2013
- 56
- 0
- 0
Hi, I've been researching for over two weeks now.
Ive been running three boxes here at the house since 2005. (So, it's been awhile since I've shopped/paid attention to the new stuff out now. Yes, I know that in about 6 months DDR4 RAM and NEW CPU's will be out for both AMD and Intel.)
Two AMD's ( Opteron 165 and Athlon 64 X2 4200+) and an Intel Pentium D-930.
Even my laptop is an old Dell Inspirion with an Intel Dual Core in it. Of course EVERYTHING I have here is using OLD regular Low Density DDR RAM. The Opteron is running REG/BUFF ECC RAM though.
The 4 Video cards between the three boxes.
The AMD CPU's are using a GeForce 6800 GT and a Asus GeForce 6200.
The Pentium D has a VisionTek HD 4550 and a Zotac Ion GT 218.
I wrote the above to give whoever comes here a good release of endorphins through the act of Belly Shaking Laughter!! Lulz
So, I've decided to build ONE NEW and up to date system. Tired of how SLOW these boxes are and having to find USED parts for them.
Here's the crux of it, I was all set to get an i7 3770k (I can't justify the cost difference to go up to the socket 2011 i7 3930k right now.) and then found that the VT-D and VT-X are not enabled in the socket 1155 i7 K series CPU's.
So, I thought I would go with the i7 3770 since it does have the virtualization instructions enabled for my VMware Workstation VM's that I run.
Then I found that the Z77 and H77 chipsets don't support ECC RAM!!!! Nor do ANY of the i7 CPU's.
So, now it was time to look at the Xeons. This made me sad since I had visions of doing some SERIOUS overclocking with the i7 3770k and some 2400 DDR3 RAM. Oh well, back to reality. LOL
I know that the cost difference between the E3 1245v2 and the E3 1275v2 really isn't worth it for the 100 mhz clock speed difference. But, the 1275v2 has a 7 year support cycle and you can see from what I wrote above that I tend to keep systems for quite awhile.
I'll list the components for 3 builds I'm looking at and then get back "my" concern/problem.
The Xeon Workstation Build:
CPU
Intel Xeon E3 1275V2 Ivy Bridge
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16819117282
MB
Asus P8C WS (Has the C216 chipset in it for the ECC Ram.)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813131849
PSU
Corsair AX860i
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16817139041
RAM (Unbuffered/Unregistered ECC )
Kingston DDR3 1600 (4x8) 32GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820239371
Case
Fractal Design Define XL R2
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16811352029
GPU
Sapphire Flex Dual X HD 7950 with Boost
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814202007
SSD
Samsung 840 Pro 512GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820147194
HDD
(x2) WD RE4 SATA II 2TB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16822136579
Seagate Barracuda SATA III 7200rpm 2TB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16822148910
Blu Ray
Asus Black 14x
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16827135302
Case Fan (Only need 1 more for this case.)
Noctua 140mm PWM
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16835608034
CPU FAN
Cooler Master Hyper TX3
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16835103064
Monitor
(2) Dell Ultrasharp U2412M
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16824260047
That's the workstation build I've come up with so far.
I do have an account with Newegg, Amazon, and BestBuy but the last time I had do a REAL build I had a Brick & Mortar Computer Warehouse Store I could just drive to and get my parts. If there was a problem I just drove back over and get a new one right away.
So, of course I'm now much more concerned about getting the components RIGHT that will WORK together than I was in past builds. Hence me posting in here.
I run VMware Workstation VM OS's and will DEFINITELY need to have a permanent Windows 7 32 BIT running to keep using my OLD software. Lulz
This is why I'm getting the 32GB of RAM and do want the HT on the CPU. This of course FORCES me to use Win x64 now. (My other MB's maxed out at 4GB of RAM so I just kept using the x86 OS's.)
I also use Auto Cad from time to time and I'm looking to upgrade my Adobe CS 4 to maybe 5 or 6.
I have only ONE LCD monitor and it's a Dell Ultrasharp 1700FPT and ALL of my other Monitors are 19 & 20 inch Flat Screen NEC CRT's. (Go ahead, laugh, I understand.) Hence the need for at least two of the 24" LED/LCD monitors. Figured I'd use the 1700FPT in Portrait Mode for my 3rd monitor with the Flex Vid card until I can afford a third 24".
I have a 4TB external HD and 2 3TB externals that are USB 3.0 so that too was a factor in the MB I chose. I also have 3 more USB 2.0 externals I'd like to hookup as well.
I've kept AWAY from Gaming on the Computer or I'd NEVER get any work done!! lol When I do game it's RPG's on the Xbox 360 like Skyrim. (I see that it's available for the computer and that the HD 7950 runs it quite well and I also hear tell that it kinda looks PRETTY GOOD on those eIPS UltraSharp 24" panels. I'm in trouble!! lulz)
I had thought about running Crossfire, but it would seem that for what I'll be doing with the computer it really won't be that big a benefit right now.
I was a little worried about going to the 860 watt PSU over say a 650 PSU due to not being certain yet if I can keep it at 50 to 80% load for the best efficiency. Figured I'd err on the side of too much rather too little.
I had been SET on the SeaSonic X 1250 in case I were to run Crossfire. But figured it was overkill for now. That and I know they make the Corsair PSU's, but after reading about SeaSonic Customer support and the STIFF cables, I figured I'd give Corsair a shot since they seem to have pretty good support.
I think that 860 PSU should handle me putting the PCI x1 Ion GT 218 card and the PCI 2.0 HD 4550 in the board to dedicate them to my VM's. That and maybe a USB 3.0 card in the PCI slot.
I'll be reusing a couple of WD RE4 500GB SATA II's in a Windows Software RAID 0 for data retrieval and writing with the SSD. They only have about 8,000 hours on them in the RAID 0 I had them in. I like the smaller 500GB drives for RAID 0 since "I" feel they respond faster. I know that a Raptor would be quicker, but these 7200 rpm RE4's are giving me 165mbs video file transfers on these Socket 939 MBs. So I "think" they'll do OK for this new build.
The OS and ALL programs will be on the SSD. I'm sick and TIRED of these SLOW computers.
The two 2TB WD RE4 drives will be for data backup. One for the SSD and RAID. The other to backup the Seagate SATA III 2TB. I know that SATA III for a HDD is bologney, but all 4 of my onboard SATAII ports will be filled with the 4 WD drives. So, that only leaves me the two SATA III for the SSD and the Seagate.
I'll be using the two 3TB externals to backup the two RE4 2TB backup drives.
I'm STICKING to using ONLY 2TB and below drives for any Windows OS. I'm fine in EXt4 using above 2 TB's though.
Ok, the only difference with the next build will be the CPU, RAM, and MB. The rest will be the same as the Xeon Build.
Intel i7 3770 Build:
CPU
i7 3770 Ivy Bridge
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16819116502
MB
Asus P8Z77 WS
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813131822
RAM
Mushkin Enhanced Red Line DDR3 1600 (4x8) 32GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820226385
For the i7 3770k O.C. Build I would have used the same MB as above in the 3770 build. Only the CPU, RAM and CPU Cooling would have changed.
CPU
I7 3770k Ivy Bridge
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16819116501
RAM
G Skill RipJaws Z Series DDR3 PC2400 (4x8) 32GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820231522
CPU Cooler
Corsair H100i (Has 3/8" water hose vs. 1/4" in the H100 and H110.)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16835181032
My REAL problem is that I fell IN LOVE with the Asus P8Z77 WS MB right after I first decided on the 3770k. Then I found out that not only do the i7 CPU's NOT support ECC ram but that the Z77 & H77 chipsets don't either. This board will take the Xeon V2 IB CPU's but NOT with ECC Ram!!
I keep talking about the ECC ram. To "me" the only REAL ECC ram is Registered/Buffered. Not this Unbuffered/Unregistered stuff.
But, it's better than NOT having ECC at all and I suppose it is a clock cycle or two faster.
I loved the 4 SATA III ports for future SSD expansion and the 6 SATA II ports as well. Not to mention that the board has more features and better heat sinks.
So here is what I'm down to, I can go the Xeon route and have at least some kind of ECC but have to go with the Asus board with LESS features.
I could go the 3770 route and "almost" have all the same features as the Xeon. With the exception of ECC ram and the Flexible Memory Control features. The VM stuff seems to be the same. Oh, and I'd be giving up the 7 year life cycle support. I'd get to use the MB I really want with the expansion options and even thoug its not a K/unlocked CPU I could use the Turbo stepping in the Z77 chipset that this board's BIOS and CPU support to get it up around 4.2Ghz. (Not certain that the C216 chipset will let me do the same in the BIOS.) I really dont want to mess with the Bclk.
Then I could just get all CRAZY and go with the 3770k. I would lose some of the VM features, but I've read where some guys are still using VMware Workstation with it. I would still get the MB I REALLY like and I could play around with DDR3 PC 2400 ram (Did I mention that I'm using only DDR 400 right now. LOL) and some over clocking.
BTW, I like having the Video on the CPU in case any or all of my video cards ever go down. Another reason I'm NOT looking at the AMD FX8350 or the Xeon's ending in 0.
So, If you took the TIME to read this post/plea for some advice or confirmation please leave your thoughts in a reply.
I thank you for taking the time to go through this.
I use to wonder why anyone would take the time out of their busy lives to help someone without getting paid.
Back in 2002 I found a Golf Forum. I use to be an Independent Professional Golfer who played the Mini-Tours when I was younger. (Almost 50 now.)
I have over 12,000 posts there now and most of those were after going to Youtube to view someone's golf swing and then do my best to help them with their problem for free.
I love golf and therefore enjoyed helping them. Hopefully it's the same for you here that really enjoy not only using but thinking about computers and solving problems.
Thanks again!!!
P.S. Im leaning heavily towards the Xeon due to the ECC & stability. So, I need to know if those components will/should work together.
You saw how I feel about my data by using Enterprise drives for my RAID and Backups. Then also having double backups, both internally and externally. (Can't afford a REAL dedicated server or even a NAS right now.)
Those backups do me no good if the RAM is throwing CORRUPT data to everything without me knowing it until it's too late.
Yes, I need to setup OFF SITE backups as well. Lulz
Ive been running three boxes here at the house since 2005. (So, it's been awhile since I've shopped/paid attention to the new stuff out now. Yes, I know that in about 6 months DDR4 RAM and NEW CPU's will be out for both AMD and Intel.)
Two AMD's ( Opteron 165 and Athlon 64 X2 4200+) and an Intel Pentium D-930.
Even my laptop is an old Dell Inspirion with an Intel Dual Core in it. Of course EVERYTHING I have here is using OLD regular Low Density DDR RAM. The Opteron is running REG/BUFF ECC RAM though.
The 4 Video cards between the three boxes.
The AMD CPU's are using a GeForce 6800 GT and a Asus GeForce 6200.
The Pentium D has a VisionTek HD 4550 and a Zotac Ion GT 218.
I wrote the above to give whoever comes here a good release of endorphins through the act of Belly Shaking Laughter!! Lulz
So, I've decided to build ONE NEW and up to date system. Tired of how SLOW these boxes are and having to find USED parts for them.
Here's the crux of it, I was all set to get an i7 3770k (I can't justify the cost difference to go up to the socket 2011 i7 3930k right now.) and then found that the VT-D and VT-X are not enabled in the socket 1155 i7 K series CPU's.
So, I thought I would go with the i7 3770 since it does have the virtualization instructions enabled for my VMware Workstation VM's that I run.
Then I found that the Z77 and H77 chipsets don't support ECC RAM!!!! Nor do ANY of the i7 CPU's.
So, now it was time to look at the Xeons. This made me sad since I had visions of doing some SERIOUS overclocking with the i7 3770k and some 2400 DDR3 RAM. Oh well, back to reality. LOL
I know that the cost difference between the E3 1245v2 and the E3 1275v2 really isn't worth it for the 100 mhz clock speed difference. But, the 1275v2 has a 7 year support cycle and you can see from what I wrote above that I tend to keep systems for quite awhile.
I'll list the components for 3 builds I'm looking at and then get back "my" concern/problem.
The Xeon Workstation Build:
CPU
Intel Xeon E3 1275V2 Ivy Bridge
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16819117282
MB
Asus P8C WS (Has the C216 chipset in it for the ECC Ram.)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813131849
PSU
Corsair AX860i
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16817139041
RAM (Unbuffered/Unregistered ECC )
Kingston DDR3 1600 (4x8) 32GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820239371
Case
Fractal Design Define XL R2
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16811352029
GPU
Sapphire Flex Dual X HD 7950 with Boost
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814202007
SSD
Samsung 840 Pro 512GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820147194
HDD
(x2) WD RE4 SATA II 2TB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16822136579
Seagate Barracuda SATA III 7200rpm 2TB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16822148910
Blu Ray
Asus Black 14x
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16827135302
Case Fan (Only need 1 more for this case.)
Noctua 140mm PWM
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16835608034
CPU FAN
Cooler Master Hyper TX3
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16835103064
Monitor
(2) Dell Ultrasharp U2412M
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16824260047
That's the workstation build I've come up with so far.
I do have an account with Newegg, Amazon, and BestBuy but the last time I had do a REAL build I had a Brick & Mortar Computer Warehouse Store I could just drive to and get my parts. If there was a problem I just drove back over and get a new one right away.
So, of course I'm now much more concerned about getting the components RIGHT that will WORK together than I was in past builds. Hence me posting in here.
I run VMware Workstation VM OS's and will DEFINITELY need to have a permanent Windows 7 32 BIT running to keep using my OLD software. Lulz
This is why I'm getting the 32GB of RAM and do want the HT on the CPU. This of course FORCES me to use Win x64 now. (My other MB's maxed out at 4GB of RAM so I just kept using the x86 OS's.)
I also use Auto Cad from time to time and I'm looking to upgrade my Adobe CS 4 to maybe 5 or 6.
I have only ONE LCD monitor and it's a Dell Ultrasharp 1700FPT and ALL of my other Monitors are 19 & 20 inch Flat Screen NEC CRT's. (Go ahead, laugh, I understand.) Hence the need for at least two of the 24" LED/LCD monitors. Figured I'd use the 1700FPT in Portrait Mode for my 3rd monitor with the Flex Vid card until I can afford a third 24".
I have a 4TB external HD and 2 3TB externals that are USB 3.0 so that too was a factor in the MB I chose. I also have 3 more USB 2.0 externals I'd like to hookup as well.
I've kept AWAY from Gaming on the Computer or I'd NEVER get any work done!! lol When I do game it's RPG's on the Xbox 360 like Skyrim. (I see that it's available for the computer and that the HD 7950 runs it quite well and I also hear tell that it kinda looks PRETTY GOOD on those eIPS UltraSharp 24" panels. I'm in trouble!! lulz)
I had thought about running Crossfire, but it would seem that for what I'll be doing with the computer it really won't be that big a benefit right now.
I was a little worried about going to the 860 watt PSU over say a 650 PSU due to not being certain yet if I can keep it at 50 to 80% load for the best efficiency. Figured I'd err on the side of too much rather too little.
I had been SET on the SeaSonic X 1250 in case I were to run Crossfire. But figured it was overkill for now. That and I know they make the Corsair PSU's, but after reading about SeaSonic Customer support and the STIFF cables, I figured I'd give Corsair a shot since they seem to have pretty good support.
I think that 860 PSU should handle me putting the PCI x1 Ion GT 218 card and the PCI 2.0 HD 4550 in the board to dedicate them to my VM's. That and maybe a USB 3.0 card in the PCI slot.
I'll be reusing a couple of WD RE4 500GB SATA II's in a Windows Software RAID 0 for data retrieval and writing with the SSD. They only have about 8,000 hours on them in the RAID 0 I had them in. I like the smaller 500GB drives for RAID 0 since "I" feel they respond faster. I know that a Raptor would be quicker, but these 7200 rpm RE4's are giving me 165mbs video file transfers on these Socket 939 MBs. So I "think" they'll do OK for this new build.
The OS and ALL programs will be on the SSD. I'm sick and TIRED of these SLOW computers.
The two 2TB WD RE4 drives will be for data backup. One for the SSD and RAID. The other to backup the Seagate SATA III 2TB. I know that SATA III for a HDD is bologney, but all 4 of my onboard SATAII ports will be filled with the 4 WD drives. So, that only leaves me the two SATA III for the SSD and the Seagate.
I'll be using the two 3TB externals to backup the two RE4 2TB backup drives.
I'm STICKING to using ONLY 2TB and below drives for any Windows OS. I'm fine in EXt4 using above 2 TB's though.
Ok, the only difference with the next build will be the CPU, RAM, and MB. The rest will be the same as the Xeon Build.
Intel i7 3770 Build:
CPU
i7 3770 Ivy Bridge
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16819116502
MB
Asus P8Z77 WS
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813131822
RAM
Mushkin Enhanced Red Line DDR3 1600 (4x8) 32GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820226385
For the i7 3770k O.C. Build I would have used the same MB as above in the 3770 build. Only the CPU, RAM and CPU Cooling would have changed.
CPU
I7 3770k Ivy Bridge
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16819116501
RAM
G Skill RipJaws Z Series DDR3 PC2400 (4x8) 32GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16820231522
CPU Cooler
Corsair H100i (Has 3/8" water hose vs. 1/4" in the H100 and H110.)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16835181032
My REAL problem is that I fell IN LOVE with the Asus P8Z77 WS MB right after I first decided on the 3770k. Then I found out that not only do the i7 CPU's NOT support ECC ram but that the Z77 & H77 chipsets don't either. This board will take the Xeon V2 IB CPU's but NOT with ECC Ram!!
I keep talking about the ECC ram. To "me" the only REAL ECC ram is Registered/Buffered. Not this Unbuffered/Unregistered stuff.
But, it's better than NOT having ECC at all and I suppose it is a clock cycle or two faster.
I loved the 4 SATA III ports for future SSD expansion and the 6 SATA II ports as well. Not to mention that the board has more features and better heat sinks.
So here is what I'm down to, I can go the Xeon route and have at least some kind of ECC but have to go with the Asus board with LESS features.
I could go the 3770 route and "almost" have all the same features as the Xeon. With the exception of ECC ram and the Flexible Memory Control features. The VM stuff seems to be the same. Oh, and I'd be giving up the 7 year life cycle support. I'd get to use the MB I really want with the expansion options and even thoug its not a K/unlocked CPU I could use the Turbo stepping in the Z77 chipset that this board's BIOS and CPU support to get it up around 4.2Ghz. (Not certain that the C216 chipset will let me do the same in the BIOS.) I really dont want to mess with the Bclk.
Then I could just get all CRAZY and go with the 3770k. I would lose some of the VM features, but I've read where some guys are still using VMware Workstation with it. I would still get the MB I REALLY like and I could play around with DDR3 PC 2400 ram (Did I mention that I'm using only DDR 400 right now. LOL) and some over clocking.
BTW, I like having the Video on the CPU in case any or all of my video cards ever go down. Another reason I'm NOT looking at the AMD FX8350 or the Xeon's ending in 0.
So, If you took the TIME to read this post/plea for some advice or confirmation please leave your thoughts in a reply.
I thank you for taking the time to go through this.
I use to wonder why anyone would take the time out of their busy lives to help someone without getting paid.
Back in 2002 I found a Golf Forum. I use to be an Independent Professional Golfer who played the Mini-Tours when I was younger. (Almost 50 now.)
I have over 12,000 posts there now and most of those were after going to Youtube to view someone's golf swing and then do my best to help them with their problem for free.
I love golf and therefore enjoyed helping them. Hopefully it's the same for you here that really enjoy not only using but thinking about computers and solving problems.
Thanks again!!!
P.S. Im leaning heavily towards the Xeon due to the ECC & stability. So, I need to know if those components will/should work together.
You saw how I feel about my data by using Enterprise drives for my RAID and Backups. Then also having double backups, both internally and externally. (Can't afford a REAL dedicated server or even a NAS right now.)
Those backups do me no good if the RAM is throwing CORRUPT data to everything without me knowing it until it's too late.
Yes, I need to setup OFF SITE backups as well. Lulz
