Originally posted by: v8envy
Originally posted by: dman918
Well, would the 7600gt be better than that x850xt? Also, why not a gto2? Isn't that right inbetween a 6600gt and these cards, and at $125 (refurb, but still). Most likely the refurbs were just not fully unlockable.
That's one card to stay far far away from refurb. Overclocker Juniors are likely to have flashed it and cranked it to 600+ mhz core and ram. Either it didn't overclock very well, in which case it's < the X850XT you want, or it's fried. There's probably a scoop of Arctic Silver slopped all over, shorting things out as well. You will be paying shipping to RMA that thing, the odds of getting a perfectly functioning card are nearly zilch.
7600GT will be indistinguishable from a X850XT, except in opengl games (where it will be slightly better). And you'll be able to see what the HDR fuss is about at lower res. With the X850XT selling for $160 AR and the 7600GT for $190, it's a no brainer decision to go with the 7600GT.
If the budget is a hard $125, hang out and wait for the X850XT to hit that pricepoint, or the 7600GT to get to $150-ish.