Critique this build

downhiller80

Platinum Member
Apr 13, 2000
2,353
0
0
I currently have an "ok" system (amd 64 3000+, x1950 256mb, 1gb ddr, azuntech x-plosion, vista).

I want to upgrade to 4gb, but cant bring myself to spend money on outdated ddr memory, so am having to get a new motherboard, which in turn entails a new CPU and a new graphics card.

My aims are to build a powerful all-round PC. I'll be using it for work 8hrs a day, and don't always have music on so want it to be pretty quiet. In the evenings it'll be a part of my home theatre setup, so again quietness is important. I want to be able to play some games as well, but I'm not going to throw massive money at it to be able to play Crysis etc. In reality although I like the idea of playing games, they tend to bore me pretty quickly these days - I always feel I should be doing something else!


Current selection:

E6750
I was tempted to go for a quad-core, but from what I've read I think the performance gain would be minimal, and they put out quite a lot more heat, which in turn becomes noise to cool it down.

Gigabyte GA-P35-DS4
Not really sure how I've ended up at this choice. I've heard good things about P35 and gigabyte. Although I have an auzentech x-plosion I'd like onboard coaxial out in case the sound card dies. I also want to be able to modestly overclock the E6750 to 3GHz-ish. Although I won't be using RAID from the off, it seems silly not to buy it in case I decide to.

G.Skill 4GB DDR2-800 CAS4
Again, I'm kinda poking in the dark here, so I've gone for something mid-range. CAS4 instead of CAS5 is presumably good, but is it worth the 25% price premium I'm paying? I don't think there's any need for me to go over DDR2-800 - that will let me OC the proc to 3.2GHz (8 * 400MHz).

Sparkle 8800 GT passive
Seems a bit overkill if I'm not planning on playing many games, but anything less than an 8800 these days seems a mistake... this model has NO fan on it - apparently they run pretty hot but hopefully with a couple of near-silent 120mm case fans I'll be ok.

Vista 64 Ultimate OEM
I'll be honest, I've been using windows for 15 years or so now, and this will be the first time I've ever paid for it... I just can't be bothered with hacking around everything any more, and never knowing whether a windows update will work etc. Fook it, I'll pay.



Any comments? What should I change? What would YOU change, and why?

cheers
 

DSF

Diamond Member
Oct 6, 2007
4,902
0
71
Originally posted by: TestedAcorn
Running an 8800GT passive isn't really a very good idea, but lets say if you were willing to spend a few bucks on one of these http://www.newegg.com/Product/...x?Item=N82E16835106112 Then it would be fine. Even the 8800GT with stock fan at 100% it gets very hot. The best way to go is get the DuOrb or the Zalman VF1000 for the GT. everything else is fine.
What do you consider very hot? I have a fan profile set to ramp up my fan speed as necessary, and I never go above 75C with the fan speed at 60%. 60% isn't too loud, and 75C really isn't too hot for a GPU. That's at absolute max load - for regular gaming, like TF2 with everything maxed, I don't even cross 65.

@ the OP: As far as work, what do you use the PC to do? There may not really be any point in overclocking the chip to 3GHz anyway. As far as RAM is concerned, there's very little real-world benefit to lower-latency RAM. If you have to pay 25% extra for it, it's not worth it.
 

DerwenArtos12

Diamond Member
Apr 7, 2003
4,278
0
0
I'm kind of a DFI fanboy/ tuning guru so I'm probably more than a little biased but, the new bloodred P35 board is a GREAT board for $108.
 

downhiller80

Platinum Member
Apr 13, 2000
2,353
0
0
You say running it passive isn't a great idea, but surely Sparkle wouldn't sell it if they thought there was a problem with it? Furthermore anandtech did a review of it and whilst it did get very hot, they encountered no problems as far as I'm aware?

Any further comments, I'm about to order today. If you really think I shouldn't get the passive 8800GT can someone recommend a quietish alternative?
 

DSF

Diamond Member
Oct 6, 2007
4,902
0
71
Originally posted by: sebfrost
You say running it passive isn't a great idea, but surely Sparkle wouldn't sell it if they thought there was a problem with it? Furthermore anandtech did a review of it and whilst it did get very hot, they encountered no problems as far as I'm aware?

Any further comments, I'm about to order today. If you really think I shouldn't get the passive 8800GT can someone recommend a quietish alternative?
If you're going to get the passive GT, I would check how long the warranty period is. If they only warranty it for a year or something, there's probably a reason.
 

downhiller80

Platinum Member
Apr 13, 2000
2,353
0
0
Yeah, only a year according to the manual - but it's a generic manual for all of their 8800GTs so that's not specific to the passive model, and I won't make a buying decision based on that.
 

downhiller80

Platinum Member
Apr 13, 2000
2,353
0
0
OK, well I've bought it all now, and a Tuniq 120 tower as well. I downgraded the RAM to CAS5 stuff.