• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Critique a build, help a poor procrastinator.

Brer Fox

Junior Member
So here is my case, the old P4 1.6 just fell out of its Rascal scooter, and the venerable Radeon 9700 Pro just is not cutting it these days. Not to mention the rest of my PC sans the Crucial memory is stock Compaq from four years ago.

Now, I am an extremely cautious buyer, and I tend to get myself in some drawn-out loops of waiting for the 'next-best-thing.' But I have given myself a deadline, even though it seems I have decided to build when the industry is at quite an indecision about things like PCIe vs. AGP, LCDs, SLI, and all that jazz.

What I am aiming to build is a PC that will last me a few years, with the prospects of a video card upgrade every two or three generations, thus I am aiming for a PCIe setup. I do not care for overclocking or SLI, or anything of that nature. I will keep things pretty much stock.

So here is what I am looking at:

Motherboard: At kind of an indecision, though I wish to have a good integrated audio and a single-slot PCIe solution, so the
CHAINTECH NVIDIA nForce4 Ultra Chipset Motherboard For AMD Socket 939 CPU, Model "VNF4/Ultra" is what I am eyeing. I am just wary of the Chaintech name, and the fact that it is the first of its kind.

CPU: AMD Athlon 64 3500+ 939 Winchester 90nm. Pretty much done and done here.

Memory: Corsair ValueSelect PC-3200 DDR Dual-Kit (1GB, 2x 512) Again, decisive. Lower CAS than the Kingston.

Video Card: This is my first major hitch. I am loyal to ATI, and was looking forward to the X800 XL, but due to this ridiculous unavailability, I do not feel like shelling out $600 for a card they were placing at $299 back in December. I am looking for a card that is high-end, but not the ultra enthusiast, somewhere around where the XL is placed. What should I do here? Jump ship to nVidia or wait it out?

Hard Drive: Seagate 160GB Barracuda 7200.7 7200RPM SATA Hard Drive, Model ST3160023AS, OEM. Just recently decided to tack this on, my old 80GB is not enough. Good? I am wary of more storage, as I cannot see myself utilizing 300GB or anything like that.

Speakers: Logitech Z-680 5.1. Decisive, nice and cheap at Tiger Direct.

Case: Lian-Li Silver Mid-Tower Case PC-60. I have dreams about this case.

I am recycling my keyboard, mouse, power supply, and removable drives.

I know this is just another 'critique my build thread,' but would like a second opinion before I do something ridiculous. Thank you so very much in advance.



 
Few suggestions...

1) chaintech is decent and I have seen many of their items be top notch...

2) good choice on the cpu

3) Just get stuff that can do cas 2 at 3200....cas timings make as much if not more difference then bandwidth in these A64 systems....Dont cheapo it up with poor cas 2.5 to 3 stuff.


4) Video Card... Oh boy!!! I guess the comparison to the XL would have to be the 6800ultra which can be had for 400+, but IMO until Nvidia figures out the porblems it has screwed the NV40 and NV45 chipset users over with...I wont recommend them....If I have DVD or playback issues with my new BFG 6800 OC that thing will hit the door out of here so fast ....NO time for that crap!!!

May have to wait...I dont know a lot about ATIs or their current timelines for cards...

5)NIce HDD pick for the cash...

6) I think Lian Li cases are overrated and a waste of cash...I know ppl who have them and they some hate them immensely. The few I have seen have been rather poor design, and lacking in basic forethought oc PC cooling needs. I laughed when I hear how much ppl pay for that crap!!!

one mans opinion.....Dont get caught up into looks alone...That works in other areas of life as well!!!!
 
Well.. I guess the X800XL is about exactly what you are looking for. The other alternitave is the 6800GT PCI-e, but that isn't exactly available either. I say wait for the X800XL if you can. If not, you might want to get a cheap ass card (like a X300se) to get your computer running and then get the X800XL when it is available.
 
Back
Top