Corsair XMS TWIN stuff

chadomaly

Member
Feb 12, 2003
142
0
0
Has there been any reviews done yet to see if the TwinX XMS3500 modules really perform any better than two regular
xms3500 modules bought separately? Is this just purely a marketing ploy? I'd like to see benchmarks or reviews if anyone knows of some, but i haven't run across any myself yet
 

mboy

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2001
3,309
0
0
I just paid $74ea for 256mb sticks of Twinmos/Windbond from memoryx.net and I am running them at 200fsb 5-2-2-2 and couldnt be happier.

About $70 cheaper then the XMS I was eyeing!
 

human2k

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2001
3,563
0
0
Corsair's prices are really getting insane. $160 for two sticks of 256MB PC2700 XMS paired together. (price from newegg) As I recall, some good kinstong/samsung/crucial 256MB DDR333 sticks run $35ish, now do the math, is it worth it?
 

BuckNaked

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,211
0
76
Originally posted by: human2k
Corsair's prices are really getting insane. $160 for two sticks of 256MB PC2700 XMS paired together. (price from newegg) As I recall, some good kinstong/samsung/crucial 256MB DDR333 sticks run $35ish, now do the math, is it worth it?


Agreed on Corsair prices

also, check this link here
 

Lord Evermore

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 1999
9,558
0
76
human2k: you're comparing Crucial CL2.5 (presumably 2.5-3-3-6 rated) memory prices, 42 dollars from Crucial per modules, to Corsair 2-2-2-5 TwinX prices. While you can say that you consider it a better value for Crucial memory, you have to include the caveat that you're not comparing memory with the same performance levels. For many people, it's worth paying more per "unit of performance" to reach a high level than to get the best value per unit of performance but not reach the highest performance. As you go farther and farther, the price per unit of performance goes up as well, because it's harder for them to make modules that can perform at those speeds.

It's like buying a car: a Honda Civic will get you around, and it's inexpensive; a Mercedes will get you around too, but you get some extra features and performance that you pay extra for.

Now, Corsair's CL2.5 memory also costs 77 dollars at Newegg, which is considerably more than Crucial or other brands, so at that performance level the winner is obvious. But when you go higher performance, Crucial isn't even a competitor (and there'd be no reason to even buy Crucial CL2.5 at that price, since 2-2-2-5 is only a few bucks more; hardly anyone sells Corsair CL2.5).

But consider that you can also get Corsair 2-3-3-6 modules for only 59 dollars at Googlegear (newegg has them way overpriced). For some people, that's not a bad price increase to get CL2 instead of CL2.5 Crucial.


As for Crucial's CL3 PC3200, Corsair doesn't even MAKE a CL3 module. Crucial's is probably 2-3-3-6 if not 2-3-3-7; Corsair's slowest PC3200 is 2-3-3-6 and is only 80 bucks at Googlegear, compared to 70 for Crucial's "factory overclocked" modules.
 

LED

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,127
0
0
1st off Corsair gets their chips from 3rd Parties (ie. Sammy, Crucial, and Winbond etc) and they usually stick with contracts on bulk but have been known to switch as with the case of Crucial when they were pimping XMS 2700 for cherry picked Crucial 7.5...so all the Twinx's do is guarantee matching sticks with the same chips from the same batch which would rarely be different anyhoots.
 

mboy

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2001
3,309
0
0
Anyone NOT thinking of the twinmos/windobnd pc3200 from memeroyx.net at $74 each is out of their minds.
MIne is HUMMING along at 200 fsb 5-2-2-2- without incident.
 

LED

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,127
0
0
Originally posted by: mboy
Anyone NOT thinking of the twinmos/windobnd pc3200 from memeroyx.net at $74 each is out of their minds.
MIne is HUMMING along at 200 fsb 5-2-2-2- without incident.
I've seen you pushing that in a few threads mboy...but it was easy for me to pass on them Cas 2.5 256MB sticks when I picked up some nice looking and performing PC3000 512MB sticks of Cas 2 Kingston RAM for $80 ...still under $90 and can be had for $85 with an addition purchase :p...drool I want some more :D
 

mboy

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2001
3,309
0
0
When u can get those sticks to 200fsb @ 5-2-2-2-2, let me know how long they are stable under prime95 :cool:
 

acid16

Senior member
Sep 20, 2001
278
0
0
corsair memory is getting fairly cheap.

1GB of TwinX PC3200 Low Latency (2x512mb sticks) can be had for around $350 at newegg. Not too bad of an investment at $175 a stick, considering this ram will easily power your computer for the next 2-3 years. Think about it..... barton will go to 400mhz and stop there. Then, the Athlon 64's coming out will only be 333. Im sure AMD will bump them up to 400 after a few months, then who knows..... maybe 433. Even a processor at 433 will be easy for this ram. Thats why I can spend $350 on this ram..... cause I know lifetime warranty + 400mhz = something ill have for 3 years. Where as, those buying PC2700 for $80 will be buying new ram when the 433's come out in 2004.
 

LED

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,127
0
0
Originally posted by: mboy
When u can get those sticks to 200fsb @ 5-2-2-2-2, let me know how long they are stable under prime95 :cool:


K...I started it @ 166 and now doing Burnwizard @ 188 2-2-2 @ default v's and then there's these that can run 210 FSB 5-2-2-2 no problems but I could pass up 1 Gig of RAM for $160 :D