Corsair Air Series Question

Essence_of_War

Platinum Member
Feb 21, 2013
2,650
4
81
So the AF/SP series have performance and quiet editions in both sizes, and both additionally come packaged with low-noise adapters.

What's the difference between, for example, between the AF 140 performance w/ LNA, and the AF 140 Quiet?

I've seen lots of tests/comparisons pitting the performance against the quiet edition, but none that throw the LNA into the mix. As a result, I'm curious if the Perf Edition + LNA = Quiet Edition or if there is more to the story.
 

Aikouka

Lifer
Nov 27, 2001
30,383
912
126
If you really want, I guess I could hook up one of my spare SP120 Performance Edition fans with the LNA (that's really more of a Noctua term...), which is just a small 3-pin extension cable with a resistor on the 12V line and see what the resulting RPM is.

However, I can tell you that even the "Quiet Editions" aren't that quiet. I turn down my fans to about 800-900 RPMs, which is when they are finally quiet.
 

Essence_of_War

Platinum Member
Feb 21, 2013
2,650
4
81
If you really want, I guess I could hook up one of my spare SP120 Performance Edition fans with the LNA (that's really more of a Noctua term...), which is just a small 3-pin extension cable with a resistor on the 12V line and see what the resulting RPM is.

If it isn't trouble, I'd be interested.

I was just very curious about the existence of a quiet edition while there is also a low-noise adapter bundled with the performance editions.
 

Aikouka

Lifer
Nov 27, 2001
30,383
912
126
Alright, this is all according to the RPM readout on my Lamptron FC5 fan controller.

Corsair SP120: ~2300 RPM
Corsair SP120 + Adapter: ~1850 RPM

The quiet editions are listed at 1450 RPM, so they aren't all that close. You could probably get them even closer with different resistors.

Corsair SP120 + 47.3Ω Adapter: ~1675 RPM
Corsair SP120 + 30Ω Adapter: ~1850 RPM
Corsair SP120 + Noctua L.N.A.: ~1650 RPM
Corsair SP120 + Noctua U.L.N.A.: ~1400 RPM

I actually use two of the 30Ω adapters in series + 2-way splitter to control my Corsair AF140 Quiet Edition fans rather than rely on my fan controller. Amusingly enough, I had to rerun all of these tests, because I realized that by letting my fan sit on my case as I ran the tests, it caused enough blowback to reduce the RPMs by about 200 across the board.
 

Essence_of_War

Platinum Member
Feb 21, 2013
2,650
4
81
Nice, thanks for the data!

And your subjective noise assessment I take it is: "loud, even with the lower noise adapters"?
 

Aikouka

Lifer
Nov 27, 2001
30,383
912
126
Nice, thanks for the data!

And your subjective noise assessment I take it is: "loud, even with the lower noise adapters"?

To be clear, I'm probably a bit more sensitive to the noise overall compared to some, so my idea of "loud" might be puzzling to some! I would say that it was alright around 1600 RPM and definitely better around 1400 RPM. I didn't really find the Corsair adapter or the 30Ω adapter to be that quiet. I would have combined two of the 30Ω adapters to see what that resulted in, but I only had one left over.

Also, keep in mind that I saw a 200 RPM drop from the wind being pushed back into the blades (i.e. not open air). With those figures, the 47.3Ω and Noctula U.L.N.A. adapters seem a bit quieter!
 

Tweakin

Platinum Member
Feb 7, 2000
2,532
0
71
To be clear, I'm probably a bit more sensitive to the noise overall compared to some, so my idea of "loud" might be puzzling to some! I would say that it was alright around 1600 RPM and definitely better around 1400 RPM. I didn't really find the Corsair adapter or the 30Ω adapter to be that quiet. I would have combined two of the 30Ω adapters to see what that resulted in, but I only had one left over.

Also, keep in mind that I saw a 200 RPM drop from the wind being pushed back into the blades (i.e. not open air). With those figures, the 47.3Ω and Noctula U.L.N.A. adapters seem a bit quieter!

I have two SP120's and I've run them against my gt-14's, gt-15 and NB e-loops. At speeds under 1000, all my other drives are dead silent, but I can hear motor noise from the Corsairs...this is also up close and on a spare rad on my bench. Good looking and well built fans though!!!