Constantly Corrupt Boot Sector on non-OS Drive...

istari101

Member
Dec 1, 2004
50
0
0
Hello, all. I've got two internal SATA HDs in my rig--one 250GB, one 200GB. Both are Seagates and have performed remarkably well for at least a couple years, but I've run into a strange problem over the past few weeks:

The 200GB trouble-free drive is divided into two partitions, one being my Windows installation and the other being general-purpose storage and installations. The 250GB drive is a solitary partition and is used entirely for storage. However, the boot sector on the second drive becomes corrupt upon restarting or booting from a cold state approximately 2-3 times/week.

After such corruptions the drive always shows up as an unformatted raw partition in Windows, but I have thus far been able to "fix" it by booting into the recovery console and running /fixboot on the troublemaker drive. Now, I keep current backups of all my important materials on a couple externals, but the corruption certainly is inconvenient, and I'm wondering if it is perhaps a sign of impending hardware failure? I've reformatted the drive and restored its contents via backup and even successfully put it through a SeaTools "Long Self-Test," so I'm not sure what else is left. My Windows partition is "G" rather than "C," but I didn't think that would matter (the drive in question is "D" in the event that it did, though).

I'm not at home right now and can't post thoroughly top-to-bottom specs, but I'm running XP Professional w/SP3, a DFI Lanparty UT nf4 Ultra-D Socket 939 motherboard w/an Opty 165@2.7ghz, 2GB of Kingston HyperX memory, and an HD3870 video card. I can't remember the model on either HD, but that doesn't seem terribly relevant (although they're both SATA 1.0 drives).

Any thoughts or insights would be appreciated, because while I'm far from technically illiterate, I'm also pretty far from techno-savant status. Thanks in advance for any help. :)
 

Rakewell

Platinum Member
Feb 2, 2005
2,418
1
76
It could be the drive; however, it could also be your mobo.

Do you have another PC you can test the drive on?

On a side note, I would always keep your windows partition as C... I used to run into conflicts in XP when I used other directories for the root, setup years ago.
 

istari101

Member
Dec 1, 2004
50
0
0
I have no other machine to test the drive in, although I certainly hope I don't/haven't run into any more motherboard issues, as I originally slagged another Lanparty UT via a power FUBAR when upgrading to the 3870. Also, Windows being assigned to "G" was not my intention, but I'm unsure how to make the switch properly without reformatting (and doing a clean install is pretty low on my want-to-do list).
 

Rakewell

Platinum Member
Feb 2, 2005
2,418
1
76
Yeah, a clean install is all you can do to fix the Windows Drive assigning (I'm not sure if BartsPE has an option to change that).

You mentioned that you had other externals; are any of those 3.5s in a non-proprietary enclosure? If so, have you thought of running the drive in question in the USB enclosure? If you don't have one, you can get them next to nothing at BestBuy, Frys, Newegg, etc. If you are running it/rebooting it with 0 problems from the USB port, then at least you know that your MOBO is the culprit...

Have you swapped the sata ports on the drives? (I presume it has sata.)

Anyway. Ain't troubleshooting fun, hope it helps.

Cheers,

Rakewell



 

istari101

Member
Dec 1, 2004
50
0
0
I switched around the SATA ports on the drives between the three accessible connections a couple weeks back to no avail (one of the four is totally obstructed by my 3870), although it at least gave me a reason to improve my wiring job a bit. Also, I'd not considered running the drive as an external to eliminate the mobo as a factor, but I might consider picking up a non-proprietary enclosure from my local BB to test it out if the problems persist and/or become excessively irritating.

Truth be told, I'll probably just "make due" if it turned out to be my mobo and simply shift my heavy-lifting storage duties to one of my externals; I'm not looking to eBay another Socket 939 LanParty, and I can get along until my next system build if need be. Anyway, thanks again for your input, and, yes, troubleshooting is a blast. ;)

*Tips hat*