conroe or 939... is it that simple?

out there

Member
Mar 9, 2005
27
0
0
ok, when you look at just the cpus, intel's newest offering wins hands down, but, what about the total system cost?
i have yet to see anyone that can give a definite speed of ddr2 that is necessary for the new conroe chips, regardless, it's much more expensive than ddr400.
motherboards? how about a pretty good 939 mobo for about 60?
cpu... 100-200 for an excellent 939.

basically, one could put together a really nice machine (by pre-conroe and current gaming standards) and still have the funds to build a second one that is nearly as excellent.
OR one could put the money that was saved into paypal and actually have something there for a "rainy-day fund" (for those of you unaccustomed to that spooky 6-letter "S" word).
OR one could do what i plan on doing and (wait a week or two to see real-world conroe benchmarks and then) snag a 4400 :cough: fx60 in sheep's clothing :cough:, water cooling, 2 gpus, and a 10k rpm raid (maybe just one hdd, undecided), 2gb of 2 latency ram, and have a freakin' awesome gaming machine for one person... or 2 freakin' awesome machines for 2 people (because i already have a "blizzard-filled winter fund" ;))

don't misunderstand my message, i would probably buy a conroe myself... if all of the extraneous expenses didn't make it so silly. why should i spend twice as much to build a computer that would be bottle-necked by graphics and hdd?

critiques welcome, please redirect me if i'm wrong on this.
i am quite confident that my choices will result in me having a grand all-around pc and better lan party attendance (it's a weekly thing during the college season).

 

KeithTalent

Elite Member | Administrator | No Lifer
Administrator
Nov 30, 2005
50,231
118
116
Well I would definitely choose (actually I did) AM2 over 939 if you are starting from scratch, as it appears you will be able to upgrade to AM3 without difficulty, plus AFAIK there is no benefit to buying 939 AM2.

As for Conroe, the AM2 was a way better value for me once I factored in Mobo costs, so that's the way I went. I was starting totally from scratch though; if I would have had starting pieces already then I would not have minded the extra $$ and would have gone Conroe in a heartbeat.
 

out there

Member
Mar 9, 2005
27
0
0
but, by that time: i will be ready to upgrade and conroe will be more affordable (based on what i already mentioned). personally, i don't foresee amd having to compete with conroe for a while... and by that time i will have sold my machine to someone for somewhere in the $1200-1500 ball-park. i've started building and selling my stuff, every 6 months or so, to the people i meet at school that don't know anything about pc's, but i don't rape them like dell, alienware and falconnw. that way i am able to stay at or near the top of the league (of smart buyers), not the people who buy the best/most-expensive just because it's the most expensive