Originally posted by: RobCur
Originally posted by: WackyDan
Originally posted by: RobCur
some of you guys are too paranoid, all you got to do is copy something over it, anything will do and its not retrievable by any standard.
You are sadly mistaken.
Is not paranoid? Is not madness? OK.. :roll:
Well, first off, I'm not aware of any trivial way to tell an OS to "copy something over" a particular set of disk blocks -- it picks whatever free blocks it thinks are best. The only way I could think of to overwrite a disk without a low-level wipe program would be to have it be a non-OS disk, and completely fill it with data, empty it, completely fill it, etc. This would take far more time and effort than just wiping the drive.
Second, yes, you *can* (sometimes) recover data from a drive that has been zero-filled or overwritten with new data. It requires disassembling the platters and scanning them with more sensitive read heads than a normal hard drive has (you can pick up on small fluctuations in the magnetic field strength due to the media having been in a particular state for a long time, and sometimes parts of tracks don't get fully wiped due to slight misalignments of the read/write heads). Not something anyone is going to do unless they have a reason to believe there is *very* valuable data on a particular drive. Doing multiple overwrites (fill with zeroes, fill with ones, fill with zeroes, etc., and/or multiple overwrites with random data) makes data recovery along these lines essentially impossible.
From what I've heard, most federal government organizations wipe and then destroy any hard drives that actually contained classified data (or at least 'top secret'-class data). No sense taking risks.