CompactFlash as hard drive / SSD

WildW

Senior member
Oct 3, 2008
984
20
81
evilpicard.com
I'm considering some upgrades to my old laptop - now 5 years old and going strong. Toshiba Portege A100 with 1.4GHz Pentium M, XP Pro. Currently 512MB ram, will be upgrading that as it thrashes the hard drive a bit.

Anyhow, was considering if there were any available hard disk upgrades. It has a 160GB 5400RPM 2.5" drive, upgraded from the original 40GB a few years ago. Was looking to see if there were any 7200rpm drives around but since it needs to be PATA there's no stock anywhere these days.

Then I remembered the fad for using CompactFlash cards in IDE adaptors as a cheapy SSD a couple of years back, with the Sandisk Ultra 4 cards supposedly being quite speedy. Nothing like a proper SSD of course, but perhaps enough for a laptop that only gets used for web/office kind of tasks.

Does anyone have experience of doing this and whether it'd be usable in speed terms? I think I could live with an 8GB C drive - big enough for XP and Office. Would it slow to a crawl during writing? Die a death when using the swapfile?
 

Gillbot

Lifer
Jan 11, 2001
28,830
17
81
I tried a CF card as a laptop. It was too slow for my liking and I went back to a 2.5" drive.
 

ochadd

Senior member
May 27, 2004
408
0
76
I've used 8GB thumb drives as a persistent boot drive for a couple Linux distros and it was comparable to the older 80GB hard drive in the laptop they run on.
 

WildW

Senior member
Oct 3, 2008
984
20
81
evilpicard.com
Seems that PATA flavour SSDs still exist in the 1.8" size, and an adapter would let one slot into my laptop. Think that'd be my choice rather than CompactFlash. The old MTRON ones were meant to be pretty decent I think, and 16GB is close to affordable. Interesting :)