Originally posted by: TheVrolok
<rant>Ok... this blows my mind.. I didn't get into Penn State's honors college (Schreyer's) with a 4.4 GPA, 1520 SAT score, multiple clubs, varsity football(as as starter), and many other things... When I know kids who are quite a bit less qualified that gained admittance.. sigh.. I just don't understand these selective proceses.. Guess there goes my shot at Brown.. not that I really had one. Heh. </rant>
They may have thought you were overqualified. It's known as "Tufts Syndrome" (Tufts has been the traditional backup for the Ivies), and they may have an idea that you'll get into other top schools and probably turn Penn State down. If you tell them you really want to go there, they will let you in. Just appeal it. I had a friend do that for UT-Austin.
Brown is so random that you may get in.
But, yeah, it's a bitch. Especially with affirmative action and the wierd processes they've got. I applied to a bunch of top schools last year, but only got into Cornell, Johns Hopkins and Rice, and the latter two gave me some very nice perks (master's program guarunteed accelerated acceptance, merit scholarship money, etc.), which would make me believe I may have gotten into better schools.
But it's all a crashoot. Don't give up hope. I had a friend get into Stanford and MIT but not into UT-Austin Engineering Honors (he got into engineering, just not honors).
No offense, but you must be ill-informed if you didn't already know admissions were random. I have a couple of friends with 1600 SAT scores that didn't get into Harvard or Princeton, and a friend that's accross the hall from me had a 1570, ranked 4th in his class, had triple 800s on his SAT IIs, and still didn't get into MIT (his dad went there, too!). Again, it's a crapshoot.
Don't worry. Good luck!