The first Coheed and Cambria song I heard was "Welcome Home," off their latest album...that song alone definitely gave me a Rush/Led Zeppelin/Pink Floyd/classic Genesis vibe...I thought to myself, finally a rock band that pays tribute to the classic rock Gods of the 60s and 70s. Even the way they name their albums...and the whole comic book/sci-fi story connection to their albums...an actual concept album concept.
I go to their website, and the band's journal makes reference to Geddy Lee, John Bonham, and other icons of the bands mentioned previously...the lead singer even sounds a bit like Geddy Lee.
My first impression...a harder, younger version of Rush.
And then I made the mistake of buying two of their albums.
Pure EMO bubblegum crap...while "Welcome Home" is certainly an amazing song, it seems that the band is having a bit of an identity crisis...even their image is a mix of one too many influences...the guitarist, bass player and drummer all have the telltale short cropped haircuts and Abercrombie outfits of the EMO/indie scene...yet the lead singer has a flowing mane of old school rocker hair, and dresses the part.
If you like EMO/Indie, you will probably like Coheed and Cambria...their music is certainly diverse, although their melodies are a bit repetitive, as are the lead guitar riffs.
It's unfortunate, at least to my musical tastes, that the band was not as incredible as "Welcome Home" would suggest.