Originally posted by: AndrewR
My God, institute the draft and kill the military. It's quite simple, really. The US military today is the most professional and capable military force ever fielded in the history of the world. The reason it is that way is because we have an all-volunteer force that WANTS to be in uniform and WANTS to perform to the highest level possible. Since it is smaller, it can be trained to a very high level.
Institute a draft, and you have a much larger group of recruits, yes, but also an enormous percentage of them who DO NOT WANT to be there and who will respond to training poorly and will in all likelihood perform to a low level because of a lack of motivation. Even IF they do perform well, they will not be trained to the same level because we cannot maintain the current high standards of training while pipelining enormous numbers of conscripts.
The end result will be a dilution of talent, an increase in body counts, a VAST increase in required expenditures for every service provided by the military (medical, legal, logistics, training, housing, etc.), and an overall decrease in the usefulness of the US military.
What's amusing is that people here are blaming the Republicans for not serving, yet the military as a whole is somewhere around 80% Republican -- who isn't serving again? The liberal elites from Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, and the like are flocking to the military, right? They lean which way in the political spectrum?
Ok, last item. Roll call here: Which of the following (supporters of the draft, from above) served in the military?
1) conjur
2) dmcowen674
3) d3n
4) her209
5) Termagant
6) International Machine Consortium
7) Steeplerot
8) BaliBabyDoc
9) Perknose
BaliBabyDoc: In fact, the only place where college-educated, upper-middle class servicepeople are well represented is amongst the officers. And again . . . they aren't the ones dying in Iraq.
Here's a list of alumni
just from my alma mater who have been killed so far in OIF/OEF. One was my classmate; I knew another quite well from my time at VMI; and two I knew of but did not know personally. Another classmate of mine hit an IED and had his Humvee flipped but fortunately did not suffer any serious injuries. STFU about officers not being killed, you idiot.
Mr. Gregory Wright '95
Capt. Lowell T. Miller '93
Capt. James C. Edge '96
Capt. Luke C. Wullenwaber '02
Major Paul R. Syverson '96
Sergeant Ryan E. Doltz '00
Lieutenant Joshua C. Hurley '01
Capt. John Robert Teal '94
Lieutenant Commander David Lucian Williams '91
Mr. Charles W. Mathers '62
Here's a quote for you from the Christian Science Monitor:
Among both Army soldiers and marines, enlisted personnel have a 40 percent higher mortality rate than officers. The exception is Army and Marine Corps lieutenants - junior officers who typically lead combat patrols and who have a markedly higher mortality rate than all soldiers and marines.