Originally posted by: the cobbler
Any of
these would be good choices.
I would guess roughly this order, best to worst:
either Sapphire 9800Pro
MSI
rosewill 6600 (can be OCd near 6600GT)
Powercolor
Sapphire 9800SE
Where I am, finding any of those for less than about $140 or so is going to be difficult. On the other hand, the Radeon 9700 Pro cards can be found for less than $100, and they were pretty good. Someone is bound to want to name some FX card, but honestly the nVidia cards in that series were a poor value. You had to pay too much for the FX 5800/ FX 5900/ FX 5950, nothing much less counts, and none got you full Dx9 compatability. For nVidia cards, step back a generation to the GF 4200, 4400, 4600, all of which are good for older games, and the prices are well within the affordable range.
Presently I do have more FX's than anything else, but I got most of those while the GF 6 series was new, and
their winning performance caused a major devaluation of the FX's, even NIB ones. I don't have direct experience with other Radeons, like the 9600 (probably affordable).