Carter versus McKay

[techs]

Carter blew up a Sun. McKay blew up a solar system.
Carter figured out a way to neutralize the Priors powers. McKay destroyed the Replicators and their planet with Fran.

Carter saved the earth from the effects of black hole coming thru the Stargate.
McKay saved Atlantis by heisting a Replicator zpm.

Carter is hot. McKay hooked up with a hot doctor.

Carter can't find a guy to stick with. McKay found one who will stick with him for apparently no good reason

Carter rarely had a to carry a whole episode and when she did it was meh (e.g. Grace). McKay had many epi's all to himself. And his Cadman impersonation was epic.


Carter versus McKay.
Game on.

 

[FoBoT]

:camera:'s?

 

[EricMartello]

Worst. Thread. Ever.

 

[guyver01]

Originally posted by: techs
McKay hooked up with a hot doctor.

Jewel Staite :heart:

 

[Cogman]

Atlantis = fail, SG1 = Win. RDA for the win.

 

[EricMartello]

They should just bring back Firefly. THAT was a good show...too bad Fox fcuked it before it even had a chance. They also killed that new Terminator series right when John was about to bone his terminatrix pet.

 

[DangerAardvark]

Originally posted by: techs
Carter blew up a Sun. McKay blew up a solar system.
Carter figured out a way to neutralize the Priors powers. McKay destroyed the Replicators and their planet with Fran.

Carter saved the earth from the effects of black hole coming thru the Stargate.
McKay saved Atlantis by heisting a Replicator zpm.

Carter is hot. McKay hooked up with a hot doctor.

Carter can't find a guy to stick with. McKay found one who will stick with him for apparently no good reason

Carter rarely had a to carry a whole episode and when she did it was meh (e.g. Grace). McKay had many epi's all to himself. And his Cadman impersonation was epic.


Carter versus McKay.
Game on.

Okay, I realize Jimmy Carter wasn't the best president ever, but I'm pretty sure he didn't blow up the sun.

 

[sandorski]

hehe, the few times they went Head-to-Head, Carter won. Both great Characters, I thought McKay showed a lot more personal growth along the way. Making him the better Character overall. As for better Scientist/Nerd, they're rather equalish. Carter solved problems just as well as McKay, McKay was just more annoying while doing it. That adds depth to his Character though, so it's not necessarily a Con.

I'd Hit Carter all night long, but not McKay.

Carter Wins!

 

[cronos]

Originally posted by: guyver01

Originally posted by: techs
McKay hooked up with a hot doctor.

Jewel Staite :heart:

mmmmmm

 

[1sikbITCH]

Carter's hotness aside, I thought McKay was much more entertaining because he's so neurotic and egotistical. And there was always a hot chick somewhere on that show too.