Careers are funny - what you know vs. who you know

Joemonkey

Diamond Member
Mar 3, 2001
8,859
4
0
I used to think the "who you know" didn't used to be as important as "what you know" but I think everyone eventually realizes that is bullshit. However, I have lived both instances of it, and we will soon find out which turns out to be better.

First IT job: Didn't know anyone at the company. I started in IT making $8 doing BS jobs, building and imaging computers, moved up to repairs, then field repairs, field networking, and eventually contracted out to a law firm to take care of their day to day issues such as imaging, backups, networking VoIP, everything. My commute was 1 hour each way, and I recently had a kid, so I started looking for a job closer to home. At this point I think I was making $14 an hour.

I applied at a manufacturing company closer to home that was hiring for an IT position doing similar things to what I was doing at the law firm. I knew someone who worked there, but not in the IT department, and he couldn't vouch for my skills but ended up talking to the IT manager anyway. Two interviews later I had the job with a moderate pay increase.

At this job they were big on certifications so I finished up my MCSE and MCSA and randomly added those credentials to my resume on monster and careerbuilder, which resulted in my being constantly called by recruiters. over the course of 3 months I had 3 recruiters call me about a specific position that was a 1.5 hour drive away and I kept telling them no, I didn't want to commute that long nor did I want to move. Finally a recruiter called about the position and I said "if you can promise me $X (where $X was a 60% pay increase) then i'll do a phone interview." Lo and behold, they promised $X, I went to some interviews, got the job, and moved. I didn't know a SINGLE person that worked at this new place, so there was no "who you know" factor involved.

Since being here I joined a local chapter involved in IT and met a lot of cool folks. I really have no desire to leave this job, but someone from another company emailed me and said they had a position opening soon and wondered if I would be interested. I wouldn't have even known about the opening, nor applied if I hadn't been contacted directly. I told him to show me the money, and he sent me some scales for Intermediate and Senior

I did the phone interview a week or so ago and now have a personal interview this afternoon. If I get mid-range intermediate it would be a 8% pay raise, but high-range intermediate would be a 29% pay raise. If I get mid-range senior it would be a 23% pay raise, high-range senior would be a 41% pay increase. Not only that, but he is emailing me tips on what to wear, how to act, and what types of questions they will be interviewing me with.

This is obviously a case of "who you know" but I wouldn't be interacting with this person, nor would he even consider me for the position if it wasn't for "what I know"

is IT different than say sales? I mean, a salesman is a salesman and can be taught to sell anything at any company, which leans more towards a "who you know" aspect, but a specialized IT person with specific certs and experience with specific systems seems to definitely be a "what you know" first, then a "who you know" second.

So, is "what you know" vs "who you know" more dependent on the job type or does it all eventually boil down to "who you know" ??
 

Gibson486

Lifer
Aug 9, 2000
18,378
2
0
who you know. Lots of incoming grads are getting jobs because they have someone who can go through the filter that is HR and have their resume go straight to the hiring manager.

For sales, it's pretty much who you know. Who you know leads to what you know. If you know the right person and you have the right connections, you could easily get clients to jump to the current company you are in. Also, who you know in sales leads to knowing where the leads are.
 

mrCide

Diamond Member
Nov 27, 1999
6,187
0
76
These days everything is who you know, at least in my area. was a bit different 5-10 years ago..
 

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106
What you know is important if you are on your own.

Most of my friends from college however just got jobs through family members and now make more than I do despite having no knowledge of their field (or even a degree related to that field). The ones who had to get a job on their own... are still looking or do not like what they found.

'Who you know' is so obviously more important at my job its not even funny. Its seems like everyone here is either a brother/sister/spouse of someone that got here first. Plenty don't do jack but they can't be let go because their 'friend' is a big shot.

I still got lucky to find this job without any help even if I probably don't have much of a future moving up here. Its a good start at least.
 

MJinZ

Diamond Member
Nov 4, 2009
8,192
0
0
Who you know fields are the generic knowledge fields.

What you know fields are the critical applied fields.

So yea, if you are Chemist or Physicist, computer programmer or Engineer - do not expect to keep (or even get) ANY job if you know nothing.

If your job is something generic like sales, management, or service - you can get away with knowing very little.
 

DrunkenSano

Diamond Member
Aug 8, 2008
3,892
490
126
With a horrible economy, it's mostly who you know now. Back when the economy was healthy and growing, it's a mix between what you know and who you know.
 

TXHokie

Platinum Member
Nov 16, 1999
2,558
176
106
I've had a total of about 11 jobs thru my career:
3 from "what you know"
8 from "who you know"
Who you knows wins.
 

MJinZ

Diamond Member
Nov 4, 2009
8,192
0
0
You can get away with knowing very little in any field.

Sure, until your first 5 minutes on the job when you get sued for malpractice.

Lawsuits are a bitch for the incompetent.
 

spidey07

No Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
65,469
5
76
It's always who you know. Who you know will actually create positions for you and generally compensate you better than a similar position.
 

IndyColtsFan

Lifer
Sep 22, 2007
33,655
687
126
It's always who you know. Who you know will actually create positions for you and generally compensate you better than a similar position.

This. I was once naive and thought your skills were what mattered. My mom told me growing up it was who you knew and that it was important to socialize at work events. I ignored the advice because I thought she was wrong, but she was 100% correct.

BTW, our corporate picnic is tomorrow and I'm not going. :awe:
 

IndyColtsFan

Lifer
Sep 22, 2007
33,655
687
126
Who you know fields are the generic knowledge fields.

What you know fields are the critical applied fields.

So yea, if you are Chemist or Physicist, computer programmer or Engineer - do not expect to keep (or even get) ANY job if you know nothing.

If your job is something generic like sales, management, or service - you can get away with knowing very little.

Bolded for emphasis. To get promotions these days, the "who you know" seems to be the most important.
 

acheron

Diamond Member
May 27, 2008
3,171
2
81
One problem is that it can be very hard for someone who may want to hire you to verify "what you know". People lie on resumes, most former employers won't give out negative references for fear of being sued, "certifications" are usually BS, etc. If they go through the trouble of hiring you and you turn out to be a moron, they've wasted a lot of money. If there's someone "who you know" that the hirer already trusts, then that will make the hirer feel much better about hiring you.

Not that it never happens (my current job was based completely on "what" -- I randomly sent my resume to a job opening posted online), but the "who" part can make it easier.
 

spidey07

No Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
65,469
5
76
Bolded for emphasis. To get promotions these days, the "who you know" seems to be the most important.

Soft skills are always much more important than anything else. They're the most valuable and will make you the most money. Especially in a technical field even more so.
 

MJinZ

Diamond Member
Nov 4, 2009
8,192
0
0
Soft skills are always much more important than anything else. They're the most valuable and will make you the most money. Especially in a technical field even more so.

Until the USA becomes a bunch of retards and realize we aren't actually producing anything because no one knows anything.

OH wait, aren't you always complaining about outsourcing or /insert any other conservative statement.
 

IndyColtsFan

Lifer
Sep 22, 2007
33,655
687
126
My previous two positions were entirely on "what you know." This current position was mainly on "what you know," but the hiring manager was best friends with an acquaintance at my former employer and while this friend didn't really know me, she asked around and gave me a glowing review. :)
 

richardycc

Diamond Member
Apr 29, 2001
5,719
1
81
I think the saying is 'who you know will get you in the door, and what you know will keep you from ejected from said door' or something like that.
 

IndyColtsFan

Lifer
Sep 22, 2007
33,655
687
126
Until the USA becomes a bunch of retards and realize we aren't actually producing anything because no one knows anything.

OH wait, aren't you always complaining about outsourcing or /insert any other conservative statement.

Unfortunately, Spidey is 100% correct. But I agree with you about our dwindling manufacturing base.
 

dfuze

Lifer
Feb 15, 2006
11,953
0
71
For me it was who you know to get in the door and what I know to get promoted up to my current spot.
 

oddyager

Diamond Member
May 21, 2005
3,398
0
76
I think the saying is 'who you know will get you in the door, and what you know will keep you from ejected from said door' or something like that.

Too bad in some places its who you know that will keep you from being ejected out the door.
 

Phokus

Lifer
Nov 20, 1999
22,994
779
126
Human beings are so irrational. If i were the owner of a business, I would go out of my way to weed out professional "who you know" ass kissers.
 

MJinZ

Diamond Member
Nov 4, 2009
8,192
0
0
Unfortunately, Spidey is 100% correct. But I agree with you about our dwindling manufacturing base.

Actually, anyone with a brain would know Spidey is 100% incorrect.

Do you regularly search for services and products from people who DO NOT know what they are doing?

Let's go to do that mechanic down the street who is super nice but can't do shit! Or how about that hair salon that can't cut horse's hair, let alone human. Oh I know, we'll pick that awesome airliner company that uses planes that drop out of sky! Woo!
 

skace

Lifer
Jan 23, 2001
14,488
7
81
It's who you know simply because there are a lot of smucks that know a lot but still suck.
 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
Well a lot of anything is who you know. However that said, many that cry about it really don't know what they think they do.