Car showdown!!! Which would you choose?

Which Performance Car Would You Own?

  • Mini Cooper S JCW

  • Pontiac G8 GT

  • Porsche Boxster S

  • Mustang GT

  • Hyundai Genesis Coupe

  • Subaru Impreza WRX

  • VW GTI


Results are only viewable after voting.

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
Say you had your choice of any of these cars as your daily driver. Keep in mind that you have to pay for gas, insurance, drive the car in 4 seasons, and occasionally make trips to the store in the vehicle. Considering cost, performance, fuel economy, style, and maintenence costs, which would you choose?

Mini Cooper S JCW -- Cool, handles like a go-kart, convertible, back seat makes it a tad more useful, great gas millage. Large fan base, considered one of the best driving cars. A bit slow, harsh racing suspension, and limited trunk space. The mentioned back seat is in name only -- 1 adult sideways or two kids could fit back there.

Pontiac G8 GT -- Large, fast, and probably one of the best cars GM has ever produced. Excellent interior, large trunk, great brakes and engine. The GT only comes with an automatic (the rare GXP has a 6-speed and a Corvette LS3 engine, but good luck finding one). Nobody will be impressed that you're driving a Pontiac, styling is a bit blah, big V8 is fuel thirsty.

Porsche Boxster S -- Widely regarded as one of the best handling cars in the world. Quick, fuel efficient, and the 05' and up models are fairly roomy inside. Mid-engine mounting makes the car drive-able in a wide range environments. Two trunks gives above average storage space. Reputation for being very reliable, but maintenance costs are expensive... some owners claim $1000-$3000/yr is common on used vehicles. Car will be in the '05-'07 range to bring the price in line with other models (as the saying goes- "an entry level Porsche is a used Porsche").

Mustang GT -- Large and powerful. Has a back seat, large trunk, large engine, large everything! Aggressive styling is still attractive, but becoming a bit too common. Great acceleration, but you have to step up to the Shelby model to get decent handling (they actually used 1970's suspension technology in the lower-end cars!). Interior is OK, not best quality. V8 is a bit fuel thirsty- some owners are reporting 10mpg with a lead foot.

Hyundai Genesis Coupe -- Nice styling, nice interior (though a bit cramped), and nice performance...especially the R-Spec model. The V6 is fairly efficient, and the car is quick and very affordable. Complaints about the transmission quality pop up in many reviews. The "Hyundai" brand name won't impress people not-in-the-know.

Subaru Impreza WRX -- AWD, an excellent engine, and its racing heritage make the WRX a favorite. Newer models are scoring 0-60 times under 5 seconds, and they're fairly inexpensive to maintain. Fuel economy is average, and the interior is a bit cramped and cheap looking. Trunk space is also so-so. Styling is in the "some like it, some don't" category.

Volkswagen GTI -- Sharp, quick, and affordable. Some consider VW the "Apple" of car manufacturers...they tweak all the little details making their interiors more of an experience than a tool. One of the most fuel efficient high-performance vehicles with MPG's in the 30's. Nice styling and handling, but reliability issues abound, and other manufacturers offer more for the money.
 
Last edited:

Viper GTS

Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
38,107
433
136
WRX for best blend of fun, practical layout, and all-weather prowess.

Just don't drive it back to back with any of the V8 cars or you'll realize just how underpowered it really is.

Viper GTS
 

brianmanahan

Lifer
Sep 2, 2006
24,639
6,016
136
subaru. i would have bought one instead of the honda fit, but didnt cuz of gas mileage, expected reliability and honda bias.
 

jlarsson

Golden Member
Jul 31, 2001
1,050
0
76
You mentioned 4 seasons, so depending on how much snow you see during the winter, I'd personally go with the WRX.
 

pauldun170

Diamond Member
Sep 26, 2011
9,517
5,748
136
I have a short commute and hold on to cars for awhile.

Mini and Volkswagon are great cars but I've seen way to many VW's turn to money pits and the Mini S JCW seems way to over priced.
Boxter S will not fit 2 car seats and a 6'2 wife.
I don't bother with automatics so the G8 GT is out
While I like the Hyundai, I could see ownership wearing on me over the long haul.

That leaves the WRX and Mustang

I want to pick the Mustang GT but from what I've read the manual transmission is its glass jaw.
WRX - I've had to write this one off in the past because of the front legroom. I still do not trust Subbie turbo motors past the 100K mark.

I'd probably get the Mustang.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
If GTI, Mini and WRX are on the list, then add the Focus ST as well. 4 doors, backseat, 32+MPG on non-premium and one of the better handling FWD cars you will buy (that isn't a Mini).

Really comes down to needs. Do you *need* a functional backseat, trunk, or RWD/AWD?

G8 is nice, but it's going to be rather bloated feeling after driving others on your list. It's a very large car.
 

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106
I test drove an 05 Boxster S a few months ago... having never even driven a six speed before (only a 5 speed forester lol) that was... an experience. Car was black on black... felt like i was in a cave with an engine strapped to my back. Just too much car for me (with no experience), didn't seem like a practical DD either which it had to be in my case.

I took a 05 Cooper JCW home for a night and that car was amazing. Thing took off like a rocket and was very easy to drive. Suspension was stiff but not uncomfortable.

Is 1k - 3k a year really a lot for maintenance though? I ended up with a Cooper S and expect at least a grand a year... everything is expensive for it and everything is a problem area.
 

CraigRT

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
31,440
5
0
I say G8, but GXP with 6MT... Definitely one of the best cars they have ever made for sure.
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Mustang.

I have loved the mustang series (well all but the mustang II).
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
I say G8, but GXP with 6MT... Definitely one of the best cars they have ever made for sure.

The story of the G8 is pretty cool and sad at the same time. It's essentially an Australian Holden Commodore that was brought to the US and rebadged. They didn't sell well at at, and the GXP version only sold around 2000 or so cars. Pontiac went belly-up, and the car was forgotten for a year or so. When they started showing up on used car lots for $20K, people looked under the hood and said "HOLY CRAP! It's got an LS3 in there! And look at this interior!" Prices shot up another $10K and now you have a classic sleeper car. The GT version is easier to find and is almost as fast, but only comes in an automatic (which is sad). The G8 GXP is a better car than a BMW M5 at half the price. I understand GM is going to bring the car back as a Chevy SS in 2014.
 

Knavish

Senior member
May 17, 2002
910
3
81
For all you guys who love the Pontiac G8, I expect you to be lusting after the 2014 Chevy Impala SS in about a year... I guess it won't have the firesale pricing that some got on the G8, though.
 

JCH13

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2010
4,981
66
91
This list is fail without any Mazda love.

Mazdaspeed3 over any of the hot hatches. (Mini, WRX, GTI)

Miata of any flavor over he RWD sporty cars (Boxster, Genesis)

Never been a huge pony car fan, so G8 and Mustang GT are out...

..oh hey, look at the cars I own... :D
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
This list is fail without any Mazda love.

Mazdaspeed3 over any of the hot hatches. (Mini, WRX, GTI)

Miata of any flavor over he RWD sporty cars (Boxster, Genesis)

Never been a huge pony car fan, so G8 and Mustang GT are out...

..oh hey, look at the cars I own... :D

The Miata isn't on the list for a reason. They ruined its looks, if you're over 6' tall you won't fit, and it's very underpowered.

miata.png
 
Last edited:

Baked

Lifer
Dec 28, 2004
36,052
17
81
I love anything Porsche. The newest model of Boxster S is damn good looking.
 
Feb 10, 2000
30,029
67
91
The four seasons thing really matters because I live in Minnesota. With that in mind, I think for me it would be down to the JCW Mini or the WRX (with the GTI a dark horse possibility). I'd have to spend some quality time (at least an extended test drive) with each to be sure. I think I'd still prefer my E90 330i as a daily driver to any of these, though.
 

xSkyDrAx

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2003
7,706
1
0
Agreed. Didn't think of it. Zippy little car, but the smiley-face styling is a turn off to some.

You can just put it in that category with the WRX where some people like the look and some people just hate it. Get it in black to minimize smiley face. The rest of the car's style is very nice though. The side profile is very sleek.

Interior is 2nd only to the GTI at this point but some of the interior decor may turn you off. Aside from that, great great car and very affordable.
 

AMCRambler

Diamond Member
Jan 23, 2001
7,715
31
91
Does the hypothetical purchaser have kids that will need to ride in the back? If yes? WRX. If no, Mustang GT with a pair of snow tires on a two spare rims for the winter.
 
Feb 10, 2000
30,029
67
91
Does the hypothetical purchaser have kids that will need to ride in the back? If yes? WRX. If no, Mustang GT with a pair of snow tires on a two spare rims for the winter.

Does anyone seriously use just two snow tires? That seems like a recipe for disaster. I drive a RWD car with snow tires in MN and sure as hell wouldn't want to have only the driven wheels have traction.
 
Last edited: