Car Insurance question

Status
Not open for further replies.

thecoolnessrune

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2005
9,673
583
126
Ok, so my truck is registered in Georgia as is its insurance. I'm currently in Wisconsin.

I let my friend drive my truck with me in it.

My friend is insured on a policy that obviously does not include my truck.

What if this friend gets my truck into an accident within the state of Wisonsin? Whose insurance pays if its the friend's fault? What if its not his fault but the fault of the driver of other vehicle that was collided with?

Just trying to get that sorted out.
 

woodie1

Diamond Member
Mar 7, 2000
5,947
0
0
AFAIK you insure your truck and anyone you give permission to drive it is covered.
 

Jeff7181

Lifer
Aug 21, 2002
18,368
11
81
If your car is insured it's insured no matter who is driving. If you're driving an uninsured car, your liability insurance covers you.
 

thecoolnessrune

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2005
9,673
583
126
Originally posted by: Jeff7181
If your car is insured it's insured no matter who is driving. If you're driving an uninsured car, your liability insurance covers you.

Alright, so if my friend crashes my truck my insurance pays for it even if my friend is insured himself?

In some ways that kinda sucks :p
 

Jeff7181

Lifer
Aug 21, 2002
18,368
11
81
Originally posted by: thecoolnessrune
Originally posted by: Jeff7181
If your car is insured it's insured no matter who is driving. If you're driving an uninsured car, your liability insurance covers you.

Alright, so if my friend crashes my truck my insurance pays for it even if my friend is insured himself?

In some ways that kinda sucks :p

Yes. And yes... your premium may go up.

Now if you claim the truck was stolen by your friend... things may get more complicated...
 

sactoking

Diamond Member
Sep 24, 2007
7,633
2,894
136
Originally posted by: thecoolnessrune
Ok, so my truck is registered in Georgia as is its insurance. I'm currently in Wisconsin.

I let my friend drive my truck with me in it.

My friend is insured on a policy that obviously does not include my truck.

What if this friend gets my truck into an accident within the state of Wisonsin? Whose insurance pays if its the friend's fault?

I'm not an expert in Wisconsin law and I skimmed the DOI provisions in Wisconsin and saw nothing explicit to this scenario, so I will answer generally.

In general, your friend has implied permission to drive your vehicle. That means he is covered under your policy. Additionally, he should be covered under his policy as well since it should cover him in "any other vehicle" or something to that effect. The question then becomes "Which policy pays?"

Generally, when multiple policies cover an accident one is considered primary and the others are considered excess. Being your vehicle, your coverage should be considered primary and his coverage should be considered excess. That means that his coverage won't pay anything until either your property damage or liability limits are reached. Wisconsin may be different. I'm pretty sure Massachusetts gives primary responsibility to the driver's policy not the owner's and Wisconsin may be the same. But generally it's the owner's primary responsibility.

What if its not his fault but the fault of the driver of other vehicle that was collided with?

Just trying to get that sorted out.

In that case, the other owner's policy should pay. If you have Med/PIP coverage it may cover your friend since he was in your car. His Med/PIP coverage would cover him also since he was "in, on, around, or near" a car. If liability is disputed, your collision coverage would cover the car, his would not. If he was uninsured/underinsured both policies would cover, but it would be a matter of determining primary coverage (as above).

 

Jeff7181

Lifer
Aug 21, 2002
18,368
11
81
Is Wisconson a no-fault state? I know Michigan is... so if my car is parked in a parking lot and someone drives into the side of it, my insurance pays for the damage, not the idiot driver that hit a parked car.
 

thecoolnessrune

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2005
9,673
583
126
Originally posted by: waffleironhead
Your girlfriend got into an accident while driving your truck eh?

My girlfriend isn't driving it right now :p It's actually a local friend that I let drive it around town with me in it (cause I honestly dont like driving the land barge) :p

I was just wondering that given my permission to drive it, whose insurance is liable to pay for the repair and / or totalling cost of my vehicle should it get into an accident.
 
Dec 26, 2007
11,782
2
76
Originally posted by: sactoking
Originally posted by: thecoolnessrune
Ok, so my truck is registered in Georgia as is its insurance. I'm currently in Wisconsin.

I let my friend drive my truck with me in it.

My friend is insured on a policy that obviously does not include my truck.

What if this friend gets my truck into an accident within the state of Wisonsin? Whose insurance pays if its the friend's fault?

I'm not an expert in Wisconsin law and I skimmed the DOI provisions in Wisconsin and saw nothing explicit to this scenario, so I will answer generally.

In general, your friend has implied permission to drive your vehicle. That means he is covered under your policy. Additionally, he should be covered under his policy as well since it should cover him in "any other vehicle" or something to that effect. The question then becomes "Which policy pays?"

Generally, when multiple policies cover an accident one is considered primary and the others are considered excess. Being your vehicle, your coverage should be considered primary and his coverage should be considered excess. That means that his coverage won't pay anything until either your property damage or liability limits are reached. Wisconsin may be different. I'm pretty sure Massachusetts gives primary responsibility to the driver's policy not the owner's and Wisconsin may be the same. But generally it's the owner's primary responsibility.

What if its not his fault but the fault of the driver of other vehicle that was collided with?

Just trying to get that sorted out.

In that case, the other owner's policy should pay. If you have Med/PIP coverage it may cover your friend since he was in your car. His Med/PIP coverage would cover him also since he was "in, on, around, or near" a car. If liability is disputed, your collision coverage would cover the car, his would not. If he was uninsured/underinsured both policies would cover, but it would be a matter of determining primary coverage (as above).

This.

I'm not at work, so I can't check stuff for WI specifically but in general this is the case.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.