• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Car gurus...

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: Zenmervolt
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
Originally posted by: Zenmervolt
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
The wrong oil viscosity and worn rings can cause white smoke upon startup, that would go away when the engine reaches "normal" temp.

No, oil thins as it heats. Even though the viscosity number increases for multi-weight oil, it is still thinner once it's hot. If the rings are going, it will smoke more than just at start-up. And again, the smoke will not be white, it will be blue-grey.

ZV
Correct, but the worn rings expand under the heat.
Not enough to seal.

ZV

Try changine oil when the car is cold, then when it's hot and tell me it doesn't thin. Of course it's thinner. The viscosity is still within spec, but it's definitely thinner.
 
As someone already mentioned, Eli, I think, it is normal for any car to put out white clouds of condensation on cold starts. This is due to the catalyst process mostly, as it produces water, and also is worse in more humid climates.

If it goes away after a few miles it is completely normal.

If it doesn't, then smell it. If it is sort of a sweet smell, that's antifreeze burning....and that ain't good.

Oil smoke is generally blueish. Gas smoke can either be black or white, depending on how rich it is.
 
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
Originally posted by: Zenmervolt
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
Originally posted by: Zenmervolt
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
The wrong oil viscosity and worn rings can cause white smoke upon startup, that would go away when the engine reaches "normal" temp.

No, oil thins as it heats. Even though the viscosity number increases for multi-weight oil, it is still thinner once it's hot. If the rings are going, it will smoke more than just at start-up. And again, the smoke will not be white, it will be blue-grey.

ZV
Correct, but the worn rings expand under the heat.

Not enough to seal.

ZV

Depends on the wear IMO.
ALL rings expand when hot. That's why there is a gap when cold, so it doesn't touch when it expands.
And Zim is correct in certain circumstances. Worn rings don't always smoke all the time. I've seen hundreds of cars that only smoked under a heavy load, such as taking off from a stop light, and the rings were the problem.
Also seen cars with worn rings that only smoked when you downshifted the car to slow down. They were fine under accel, but turned into mosquito killers if you downshifted.

Then you have the ones that just smoke all the time. And there are some with worn rings that never noticeably smoke...they just use too much oil.
Ford used to have that problem in the 80's with the 5.0's....they actually told people that one quart every 500 miles was acceptable consumption. Then they had a TSB for higher-tension rings to fix it, but it cost a bit of horsepower.

It really just depends.
 
Originally posted by: Pacfanweb
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
Originally posted by: Zenmervolt
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
Originally posted by: Zenmervolt
Originally posted by: Zim Hosein
The wrong oil viscosity and worn rings can cause white smoke upon startup, that would go away when the engine reaches "normal" temp.

No, oil thins as it heats. Even though the viscosity number increases for multi-weight oil, it is still thinner once it's hot. If the rings are going, it will smoke more than just at start-up. And again, the smoke will not be white, it will be blue-grey.

ZV
Correct, but the worn rings expand under the heat.

Not enough to seal.

ZV

Depends on the wear IMO.
ALL rings expand when hot. That's why there is a gap when cold, so it doesn't touch when it expands.
And Zim is correct in certain circumstances. Worn rings don't always smoke all the time. I've seen hundreds of cars that only smoked under a heavy load, such as taking off from a stop light, and the rings were the problem.
Also seen cars with worn rings that only smoked when you downshifted the car to slow down. They were fine under accel, but turned into mosquito killers if you downshifted.

Then you have the ones that just smoke all the time. And there are some with worn rings that never noticeably smoke...they just use too much oil.
Ford used to have that problem in the 80's with the 5.0's....they actually told people that one quart every 500 miles was acceptable consumption. Then they had a TSB for higher-tension rings to fix it, but it cost a bit of horsepower.

It really just depends.
Yeah, absolutely. But in those cases it's not completely gone, it just depends on the circumstances. 😉

If he could get it to smoke while accelerating, decelerating, etc... then our advice would be different. But if it's just some white smoke at startup, and only sometimes... it's most likely condensation and nothing to worry about.

The term "smoke" is used losely.
 
Originally posted by: Eli
If he could get it to smoke while accelerating, decelerating, etc... then our advice would be different. But if it's just some white smoke at startup, and only sometimes... it's most likely condensation and nothing to worry about.
Yep, pretty much my opinion, too.

Amazing how many customers over the years I've had complain about normal condensation from the exhaust in the morning.

Also had lots of them think that the condensation from the A/C drain was something wrong, too. "I've had the car 2 years and I swear it's never done that before".
Me: "Sir/Ma'am, we're in North Carolina, it's 98 degrees and 90% humidity...if your A/C isn't leaking it isn't working properly."
 
Back
Top