Originally posted by: WHAMPOM
1500 homes gone now and a $Billion+ in damages.
Just wait and watch how the Insurance Companies screw their policy holders.
Originally posted by: RichardE
GF and I almost lost out place in La Jolla Was pretty scary tbh. Luckily it turned out ok.
Originally posted by: EagleKeeper
People do not like the sound of a control burn and will try to prevent it for some of the following reasons.
1) The fact that a fire is being deliberately set.
2) The smoke and ash may blow into their property and inconvience them
3) Some worry about how it may affect wildlife.
4) The asthetic appeal of looking at a blacked patch of land for up to 6 months.
Now if people who live in such areaas would actually clear brush and dead debris from their house back by at least 50 feet to 50 yds, they would have a natural firebreak.
And if controlled burns were done in canyons/brush areas where no one has built, but are nearby to homes, that would also act as a natural fire break/reduction.
Animals will move out of the way of controlled burns as long as it is not in the early spring when the young are unable to move.
The controlled burns will also allow new growth of the grass and also allow the conifer trees to produce seeds for new growth.
Originally posted by: randym431
You know, this is a lot of hype from the media on this story. Yes the fires are awful and the damage, but this is "typical". It happens almost every year, or other year. I remember in 1983 when I drove up from san diego to LA for business, the hills on both sides of the freeway were a blaze. It was like driving thru a movie set.
The problem has always been out there is that people build where they should not, like on cliffs, then wonder why their homes fall in the ocean. Southern CA is a desert. It gets rain in the spring, and thats it.
You don?t build in places that you can not clear the brush away from your home, or the fires will eventually get you.
Yes its worse this year, but in "this" case its not global warming or Bible prophecy. Its just a very bad year for fires.
Originally posted by: Pabster
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
This seems like an annual event.
Yep. What's sad is several of the fires are apparently arson.
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Just more of doing everything that can be done wrong here.
Originally posted by: Pabster
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Just more of doing everything that can be done wrong here.
Who's responsible, Dave?
Originally posted by: ironwing
Dave your article on the helicopters and planes being grounded was just a grandstanding Congressman yapping in ignorance.
Forest Service fire aircraft rules were developed the hard way...people died...lesson learned...new rule...more people died...new lesson learned...new rule...
Originally posted by: Lemon law
This somewhat ties in with the 60 minutes piece last Sunday. But the thesis of 60 minutes was that this must be global warming because we are seeing he fires get bigger.
With 200,000 acre fires being a past rarity and now they are common.
While I certainly believe in global warming, I find the 60 minutes claims hard to swallow for two reasons. (1) There have been a lot of studies to the effect that the longer a fire is delayed, the more fire prone an area becomes. (2) Options with things like backfires and just bull dozing firebreaks become greatly reduced when there are houses cropping up in former wilderness areas.
The Santa Anna winds that drive the fires have been occurring with regularity stretching back many centuries and I see no real evidence they are stronger now than in the past. But a long standing policy of preventing past fires now come back to bite because there are no existing previously burned over areas to prevent the unrestricted continuation of fires. And the other variable, the oxygen content in the air remains unchanged.
And the post by ayabe may well touch on what the long term solution is in California. All else just kicks the can down the road dangerously.
Originally posted by: JD50
Originally posted by: ironwing
Dave your article on the helicopters and planes being grounded was just a grandstanding Congressman yapping in ignorance.
Forest Service fire aircraft rules were developed the hard way...people died...lesson learned...new rule...more people died...new lesson learned...new rule...
I've heard this as well. I'd like to see Dave's response to this and/or the thread title changed.
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: JD50
Originally posted by: ironwing
Dave your article on the helicopters and planes being grounded was just a grandstanding Congressman yapping in ignorance.
Forest Service fire aircraft rules were developed the hard way...people died...lesson learned...new rule...more people died...new lesson learned...new rule...
I've heard this as well. I'd like to see Dave's response to this and/or the thread title changed.
Sorry, no excuses allowed.
The C-130's not being ready happened on your leadership's watch.
Originally posted by: JD50
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: JD50
Originally posted by: ironwing
Dave your article on the helicopters and planes being grounded was just a grandstanding Congressman yapping in ignorance.
Forest Service fire aircraft rules were developed the hard way...people died...lesson learned...new rule...more people died...new lesson learned...new rule...
I've heard this as well.
I'd like to see Dave's response to this and/or the thread title changed.
Sorry, no excuses allowed.
The C-130's not being ready happened on your leadership's watch.
Is it possible for you to cut that shit out, just for one freaking thread?
After spending the last week and a half at Ramona Airtanker Base during the extreme Santa Ana Wind event I learned some important lessons. The first being that firefighting under the most extreme burning conditions I have ever witnessed in So Cal. is another world. I have to admit to being more than a little shell shocked. The second lesson is one that I have relearned many times. That is that the media often abandons reporting the facts and the interest of the public good to evoke an emotional response by attacking the very people that risk their lives to fight the fire in order to develop a ?hot story?. The first few days CALFIRES air program was continuously criticized for an inadequate response. Statements were made that the military could have done a better job.
Here are some facts that I am aware of; Airtanker Pilots Mike Venable, Billy Hoskins, Bob Forbes and Lynn McGrew made a valiant attempt to stop the Witch fire under conditions that tested their aircraft and airmanship to their very limits. They decided to stop flight operations only when it became apparent that further efforts would be to no avail. In my humble opinion their actions were heroic. Shortly after that no aircraft in the inventory civil or military could have survived in the wing breaking turbulence and zero visibility that existed well into the next day.
Upon seeing our Chief getting out of the Air Attack ship trying to hold back his tears, I knew that something terrible had happened on the Harris Fire. It had. Some of our Firefighters were burned over and severely injured in addition to one civilian fatality. They happened to be Firefighters that were very close to the Ramona Air Attack Base family. The US Forest Service Firefighters that rescued them were also a part of that family.
The entire compliment of the Ramona Air Attack Base deserves our praise and the gratitude of every citizen living in San Diego County. Their performance was exemplary in every way. When they ran out of water, water tenders were ordered and ran around the clock to keep Ramona Air Attack Base operational. After fighting fire all night with her husband to save her home and her neighborhood Sheri Lee showed up for work at 6:00 AM to perform her duties at the tanker base keeping everything running smoothly as she always does.
Ramona Air Attack Base is an example of the best we have to offer starting with its leadership and ending with a team of professionals. The nerve center in the tower, the ramp managers, aircraft directors and loaders are a well oiled machine. They handled a third of our total airtanker fleet and three Air Attack ships and never missed a beat.
I didn?t work out of Hemet except to reload once but I can say with great confidence that the same level of excellence and dedication to the mission was operating there as well.
On the statue of the Iwo Jima Memorial it states that ?uncommon valor was a common virtue?. After seeing our ground Firefighters putting themselves in harms way time after time to provide for the protection and safety of others I believe that they can proudly lay claim to that sacred creed.
Jim Barnes
AB, news agencies, - My lord talk about some crazy stuff going on with those news channels. Nothing short of having one fire engine and one hand crew for every 1/10 of acre for each burnable acre would have made a difference. You could have had every C-130 in the free world loading and returning and every helicopter from our NATO allies with a bucket on them and houses would still have burned. Santa Ana winds events and wildfires create extremely serious situations. A 100 mph wind gusts will usually ruin your day (one way or the other). Wildfires and Santa Ana?s have been occurring for thousands of years and will continue for thousands of more years. The only difference is about 16 million people have decided to live in the area, with 16 news channels trying increase ratings, using 16 different reporters who think they should be Division A for the day.
Mother Nature was in charge for about 2-3 days this week. However this does not mean fire orgs are not effective in limiting these types of events and averting other mega fires throughout any given fire season. Strong fire organizations (local, state, county and Fed) are a must. 12 large fires occurred this week. Dozens if not hundreds were picked up at IA this week. This was due the hard work of many of you and the financial support we have from the American people to maintain strong fire organizations.
Letterman
In '93 we were prepositioned in Orange County because of predicted Santa Anna winds. When the Topanga Canyon fire broke in Malibu we responded with a massive number of resources. We made a brave stand and were able to stop the fire at the Pacific Ocean. (We never did get any thanks from the folks from Hawaii)
I don't know that any amount of response will stop a fire when you have drought stressed fuels, high winds, low RH and warm temps. I believe that the battle is best won prior to the ignition. Why are there still homes in the interface that lack non-flammable building materials, lack of defensible space, lousy access, etc.?
Maybe with this amount of loss the insurance companies will take a leadership role in making homeowners take responsibility for reducing the fire hazard from around their homes. I know that they are the only ones who have the leverage to make that happen.
Tim
Originally posted by: ProfJohn
Hannity had an environmentalist on his show today, and not some nut job, but a respected and knowledgeable one. And the environmentalist refused to blame this on global warming. He said that there is just not enough evidence to make the claim that global warming has anything to do with these fires. He also pointed out that there was a fire in the 1890s that was twice as big as these recent fires.
Fires in SoCal are like Hurricanes in Florida and the South East, they are going to happen and there is nothing you can do to stop them. All you can do is be prepared for when they hit.