Zenmervolt
Elite member
You can see this effect by calling your insurance company and asking for 2 quotes. The first one is for a Toyota Camry XLE with a V6 and leather seats. The second one is for a Subaru Impreza WRX STI. The Camry is a more expensive car, but the insurance is waaaaaaay less. Why? Because people who buy the sporty WRX STI crash into things and kill people on a regular basis.
Actually, the actuarial tables show that Camrys are involved in more accidents. It's just that those accidents tend to be less severe (e.g. parking lot incidents).
Insurance companies don't simply charge based on the average payout, they risk pool drivers and then charge based on the maximum payouts projected for the pool. Obviously they don't charge the maximum payout to the consumers, but the rates are calculated to hedge against a worst-case scenario, not simply the "average" scenario. A small increase in the number of cars totaled can translate into an incredibly large increase in premiums for members of a particular risk pool.
ZV