My performance tire shop tire prices are about 5% more than discount tire.. But they do fantastic alignments, and the guys are honest if you don't need one. It's $20 to set up the lasers or whatever and check it.
Other places charge you for a full alignment whether it needs it or not.. So you need to find a good place.
I agree, it usually makes sense to at least have it checked, particularly if you need to warranty a tire for some reason. But, it really depends on year/make/model. Nissan with spindly suspension parts that are only held in with friction? Get it checked for sure. Domestic 4 door with beefy a-arms that lock in place? Not quite as huge of a deal.
I'm a huge michelin fanboy. It's all I use nowadays. You simply can't trust these tirerack-ish reviews where kids replace their shit OEM tires with medium quality aftermarket, then act like it's the best tire you could possibly buy just because it's so much better than whatever they had before. They cost more, but seriously.. Brakes and tires are the two things you should NEVER skimp on. It can be the difference between being injured or not - or worse. I don't understand why people spend tons of money on the best filters, plugs, things that your life doesn't depend on... Then buy 2nd tier tires.
I like the pilot super sports on the CTS-V, but I'll be lucky to get 25k out of rears and they aren't that great during our short winter season. I'm going to try the A/S 3 next since this it's driven in the rain a lot.. The A/S 3 is supposed to break loose more predictably than the PSS, grip better in the wet than the PSS, and I'm not trying to shave seconds off lap times or anything...