The guitar is only half the equation. Once you get beyond having good action and intonation (which are absolutely necessary) how it sounds depends not only on such guitar characteristics as the pickups, body material, etc, but just as much on the amp you plug it into.
I know a little something about this. I play guitar and keyboards, and I design audio electronics. Most of the stuff I design is pro (studio grade) signal processing, but one of my clients is Groove Tubes, and I'm around tubes and guitar amps, all the time.
My own guitars and amps:
1970 Martin D-28 acoustic. The voice of heaven in my hands.
Les Paul Standard copy by Mighty Might (One of the better ones from another era) with real Gibson humbucking pickups and Schaller heads.
Gibson ES-335-12 electric 12-string.
1965 Fender Deluxe Reverb hotrodded with 6L6's instead of 6V6's -- It's an easy mod
IF you know how. It's not just plug and play. This amp
COOKS!!! It gets that big fat singing sustain sound at a decent level for a small to medium room.
1963 Fender Twin Reverb (production run #4) with JBL K120 speakers. A great clean amp. I can get the same fat sound as I get with the Deluxe, but when I do, it's so freaking loud that I don't like to stand in the same county. :Q
Of course, with a client like Groove Tubes, I'm also blessed with good access to the fire bottles.
Monel --
<<I'd sure like to know how you decide on an electric. The acoustics can be listened to anytime, anyplace.>>
Acoustic and electric guitars are simply different instruments. They have the same mechanical playing method, but their voices are so different that it is like comparing a grand piano to a harpsichord or an organ.