body cams

mdram

Golden Member
Jan 2, 2014
1,512
208
106
so if a claim is made against a cop, and the body cams show the claim is false.
can the cop then sue for defamation?

just curious as this has happened a few times recently
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,350
53,969
136
so if a claim is made against a cop, and the body cams show the claim is false.
can the cop then sue for defamation?

just curious as this has happened a few times recently

Yes but they will likely lose. In order to win the cop would have to show that not only did the person make a false statement but that they knew it was false. The person would likely say 'I remembered it happening differently' and that would be that in most cases.
 

mdram

Golden Member
Jan 2, 2014
1,512
208
106
i was thinking of the sexual assault allegation, and the racial profiling stories

where the body cam shows extremely different evidence from the allegations
 

SMOGZINN

Lifer
Jun 17, 2005
14,308
4,569
136
so if a claim is made against a cop, and the body cams show the claim is false.
can the cop then sue for defamation?

just curious as this has happened a few times recently

Yes, and mattering on just what was claimed they can even charge them with criminal charges of filing a false report and perhaps even perjury since a lot of the forms you fill out to make such claims are considered under oath.

We have said all along that body cameras protect the officers just as much as the public. We want to protect good cops and catch the bad ones.
 

Darwin333

Lifer
Dec 11, 2006
19,946
2,329
126
Yes but they will likely lose. In order to win the cop would have to show that not only did the person make a false statement but that they knew it was false. The person would likely say 'I remembered it happening differently' and that would be that in most cases.

Isn't it funny that a cop can sue us for defamation but a cop can illegally arrest us, make up charges, plant evidence, cost us a ton of money for bail and fighting the charges and often times we either lose or are forced into taking a plea deal out of fear of a much longer jail sentence but a jail sentence nonetheless and a felony jacket to boot.

They can do all of that to us, it has happened untold times and continues to happen to this day literally ruining lives and most of the time we can't sue them personally. In the very rare case that we are allowed to sue them personally the taxpayers almost always cover their legal costs. They can even get qualified immunity if they aren't certain if what they are doing is illegal (ignorance of the law) which lands us normal plebes in jail. Even if they get caught red handed the vast majority of the time the absolute worst that happens is they lose their jobs and sometimes that doesn't even happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ch33zw1z

Sunburn74

Diamond Member
Oct 5, 2009
5,076
2,635
136
so if a claim is made against a cop, and the body cams show the claim is false.
can the cop then sue for defamation?

just curious as this has happened a few times recently
I think it depends. This question is too vague. Also defamation generally requires deliberate intent to spread known falsity as a means of damaging a person's reputation.