Question Blu-ray writers are they worth it, what alternatives?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

right_to_know

Member
Nov 19, 2015
78
14
71
Are blu-ray writers worth buying at this point in time. Memory cards lose their charge over time and hard discs can fail so a better solution is needed.
Are BR DL 50gb discs good enough or should people go for the writers that can manage triple layer 100gb or are those discs too expensive to make it worthwhile? Some of these writers can use M discs which are claimed to last for 100s of years.

Is there anything better around the corner. What is the best to buy for storing GBs of files?
 
Nov 20, 2009
10,043
2,573
136
Part of this is probably because Sony, the developer of the storage platform and by use of storing its movies on them, has left the organization. It is, for lack of any other words, a dying technology. Sony is fully invested in the world's ability to stream its content.
 

mikeford

Diamond Member
Jan 27, 2001
5,666
157
106
Everything now is moving toward "the cloud", and I don't trust it. OTOH I hear G5 bandwidth will be a game changer, so could be cloud and streaming soon for everybody.
 

Fallen Kell

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
6,009
417
126
encrypt and backup to cloud.
You expect some cloud service to still exist in 10 or 20 years from now? If you go by past president, if/when the companies that offer these "free" (and even paid for) services fold up shop because it is not profitable enough, people simply loss everything stored there, many times without any warning (because giving a warning tells potential investors that things are getting bad/desperate and they don't want to throw money at a sinking ship).
 

Fallen Kell

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
6,009
417
126
Network Attached Storage (aka NAS) ? Cheap, low power, with vendor support including security updates , TB worth of storage , easy accessible with full ecosystem behind them. QNAP and Synology are known leaders in this space..
For some people this might be fine. However, it is subject to attack from bad actors/viruses/ransomeware. If you want true long term storage, tape archive or optical media is still the way to go, as this lets you move them to a different site (in case of fire/flood/tornado/earthquake/disaster) such as a bank safety deposit box, where you can easily keep TB's of data secure and unable to be easily destroyed/altered (and if you are really paranoid, multiple copies at multiple locations).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Insert_Nickname

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
94,662
14,928
126
You expect some cloud service to still exist in 10 or 20 years from now? If you go by past president, if/when the companies that offer these "free" (and even paid for) services fold up shop because it is not profitable enough, people simply loss everything stored there, many times without any warning (because giving a warning tells potential investors that things are getting bad/desperate and they don't want to throw money at a sinking ship).

Then physical plus cloud. You are supposed to have multiple backup anyway
 
  • Like
Reactions: DAPUNISHER

mikeford

Diamond Member
Jan 27, 2001
5,666
157
106
Is there still any viable tape format? Was there ever?

Paranoid reliability is some combination of mirrored drives, incremental saves, ideally a keystroke level of infinite undo and undo undo, and rotation of mirrors in an offsite queue. Add to that archiving permanently and replacing oldest drive in the remote queue.
 

right_to_know

Member
Nov 19, 2015
78
14
71
USB external writers I just put a powerbank on the second USB "power" cable.

Fry's I think had 128GB thumb drives for about $25 in the latest sales flyer, for the most part that kills the idea burning data on a disc. All the smaller stuff goes on a thumb, and we have 10TB of disc, only practical backup is to mirror it to other drives.

The benefits of writing and reading data seems to point to solid state solutions and not optical or magnetic.

I have heard that those forms of data storage lose their charge eventually and start dropping data.
Is there something like a solar powered trickle charge to help avoid this problem?
 

mikeford

Diamond Member
Jan 27, 2001
5,666
157
106
I've been spending time on r/datahoarder and learned ...
LTo is a tape backup format, drives about $4k, tapes $100 for 18TB.
BD rom comes in 3 flavors, 25GB, 50GB, and BDXL 100GB. M-disc looks like best option for archival, not cheap. Some drives, aka all the cheaper ones, are known to have issues about 25GB media.

Somebody must be offering the service of burning your data to your tape, with their drive. If so maybe the best option.
 

Fallen Kell

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
6,009
417
126
LTO is a good solution that has industry backing with testing/modeling to see how long it will last as a reliable medium for storing the backup. As you mentioned the drives can be expensive, but if you don’t mind going back a few generations, things can be had pretty cheap. For instance you can find LTO5 drives for around $200-300. These still support backing up a pretty large amount of data (1.5TB uncompressed, 3TB compressed) on a single tape. You can even find some of the tape jukeboxes/autoloaders for $400-800. Tapes can still easily be found and are about $20 each. The nice thing about LTO5 is that it should support ltfs, meaning you can basically use the tape drive as a standard file system (i.e. browse the files backed up on it, and copy to/from it).
 

killster1

Banned
Mar 15, 2007
6,208
475
126
USB external writers I just put a powerbank on the second USB "power" cable.

Fry's I think had 128GB thumb drives for about $25 in the latest sales flyer, for the most part that kills the idea burning data on a disc. All the smaller stuff goes on a thumb, and we have 10TB of disc, only practical backup is to mirror it to other drives.

That said, I have a few BD burners at this point, so in "some" cases I can see putting "some" files on BD burnt discs, but so far haven't bought any.

Looks like "about" a buck each for single side 25GB, so about $40/TB, cheaper to buy hard drives.
I would prefer bluray media to usb flash drives fir backup. I use bluray to archive photos on 25gb discs. I dont remember the price but I believe it was Japanese disc's shipped from Japan (at the time they said they had the best media most reliable) its been 5 years and they show zero damage degradation.
 

Insert_Nickname

Diamond Member
May 6, 2012
4,971
1,691
136
I would prefer bluray media to usb flash drives fir backup. I use bluray to archive photos on 25gb discs. I dont remember the price but I believe it was Japanese disc's shipped from Japan (at the time they said they had the best media most reliable) its been 5 years and they show zero damage degradation.

So long as they're phase change media, the discs should do 25+ years easily. I have DVD-RAMs (no, not a typo) burned in '97-'98 that are still perfect to this day.

Edit; a few CD-Rs from the mid '90s too. Perfectly readable, but then, I did use good quality media. (Kodak Gold discs)
 
  • Like
Reactions: AnitaPeterson

mnewsham

Lifer
Oct 2, 2010
14,539
428
136
Part of this is probably because Sony, the developer of the storage platform and by use of storing its movies on them, has left the organization
Based on what? From the BDA website, Sony is still listed as a member of the board of directors.

Further sony makes big money from a Bluray extension they've been pumping out in recent years called Optical disc archive.

As of early 2020, Optical disc archive discs can store 500GB per disc and are sold in 11 disc cartridges.
This is double the density of existing consumer bluray (128GB per side for a maximum theoretical 256GB for a double-sided quad-layer disc).

So clearly, the technology isn't dead if sony has spent the last ~8 years refining and selling what amounts to enterprise-grade bluray (with a corresponding enterprise-grade price).

Now CONSUMER bluray is certainly not looking too good in recent years, little to no development, and very little reason considering the state of streaming.
 

mnewsham

Lifer
Oct 2, 2010
14,539
428
136
Not an expert but just speaking from my own experience.
Must be fairly limited experience.

At my work we have CDs from the early/mid 1990s that still work just fine, and we've moved several of our things over to Bluray without issue. Besides, anything genuinely important will have multiple copies made anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AnitaPeterson