What OS do you run? And also, what kind of format do you need? Everyone says the 3dfx one is good (don't know, have only seen one review). The TV Wonder is good if you don't use Win2k, there are only beta drivers out. You can probably get it for like 50 bucks on the For Sale Forum. The TV Wonder VE is probably 50 new, but it can only capture MPEG-1.