Of course, I'm now bouncing around pure summer tires or high performance all seasons.
The summer performance tires, in warm weather, i.e. May through September, will outperform the A/S tires.... but by how much? And at a cost of lifespan and ride comfort and noise.
But, from mid-March to May, and September until the end of November, the summer performance tires are going to be terrible, as the cold temperatures will bother them.