ATI ELITE PRO REMOTE CONTROL EDITION or WINTV PVR-150

[xboxlive]

I have an ATI ELITE PRO REMOTE CONTROL EDITION and am thinking that a
WIN-TV PVR-150 would suit me better.

I want to record, edit and maybe even sometimes play xbox on my card, which card is better suited for this use. I already own the ATI and thier software is too bulky and invasive IMO.

Please help.

 

[xboxlive]

newbie thanks all of you who responded to this forum post! :disgust: sarcasm :disgust:

 

[mooncancook]

ATI Elite has excellent picture quality IMO, though I haven't used PVR-150 for a comparison. The ATI software bundle sucks big time tho. It even made my ATI MMC un-usable, and don't even mention the remote. On the other hand 3rd party software such as GBPVR supports it now, but I haven't tested the VIVO function with GBPVR. If VIVO function works with GBPVR or whatever 3rd party software you are using then stick with ATI since you already have it.

 

[xboxlive]

Well my ATI has let me down based on its accompanying software.
I went with the Hauppage Win-Tv PVR-350.

If not, I have my more-reliable ATI ALL IN WONDER PRO to fall back on.
Pro is far better than Elite, do not know why I thought I was upgrading.