In that case would it still not be worth it? Seems like there must be something up for that to happen but I don't know what
In that case, it may be worth it. AIW 9700 pro = 9700pro performance wise. If you don't need dual head support, you would be getting basically the same performance considerably cheaper...warranty not taken into consideration. The cables from ANY AIW Radeon (perhaps Rage also) excepting the 8500DV and AIW 9600 pro will work perfectly as well. Then its just a matter of the remote (doesn't come with the nonAIW anyway, but real nice to have and needed for EasyLook HTPC interface, and the native component output. So maybe in that case. The tuner itself will work without cables (just hook coax right up) and you can hook the audio internally (CD audio cable) so that you can hear the TV without the multigang output plug.
So maybe considering the caveats..as long as you're informed
The other consideration is you won't have the ATI installation disc, so no Guideplus+ software, or ATI DVD decoders...these are not downloadable either, all the rest of the MMC software, drivers and Hydravision are freely available for download from ATI.