I just bought my first ATI card. I've always gone for NVidia based cards, but when the PixelView GF3 I got from Comp Geeks started smelling like burnt rubber and they wouldn't accept it back because it still technically worked, I needed to get something quick and wanted to spend around $100. This deal came about right on time. I couldn't pass up a mature card with 128 MB ram. I got a 4000 point jump in my 3dMark scores over the GF3, so I'm, so far impressed.
BTW, whoever tried to hide the last Radeon 8500 behind the MX400 cards at the vacaville store should have noticed that the Radeon box was a few inches wider.