Originally posted by: rivan
While it doesn't compare to you guys just finishing off the uber-raider achievements, I managed to complete 3 wings of Naxx in a group full of win on Monday
On the down side, they were using webdkp and while the per-fight dkp grants were generous, I was outbid on all 4 items I bid on. By the same priest. No loot for me.
I am convinced that a loot system strictly based on DKP sucks. Same thing goes with a system strictly based on loot council. For pugs, I prefer strict rolling for need. For guilds, I prefer a blend of both DKP and loot council. I like the "DKP" to be based strictly on attendance. From there, I want the council to use this "DKP" as a guideline. Not a rule of thumb. I like them to use it to narrow down who gets the loot, but from there decide who gets it using their own best judgment. I have found that this sort of thing if managed by the right people results in everyone getting their fair share of loot while also maximizing progression.
