AT Silencer vs VGA Water Block?

[Cook1]

I'm going to be getting this and this sometime in the near future. My plan was always to get an AT Silencer for my 7800GT, but then I saw this. So my question being, what would provide better cooling when the card is at stock speeds?

 

[JBDan]

3rd "this" all day.

 

[lobadobadingdong]

better cooling I would think would be the NV Silencer, unless you plan on adding another radiator to the mix then it would likely be the water block.