Asus RT-3200 LAN issue

ImpulsE69

Lifer
Jan 8, 2010
14,946
1,077
126
Asus RT-AC3200

I'm having an issue where WAN speeds are fine, but internal LAN speeds between clients is very slow (specifically transmit speeds look capped??) in that streaming on the network keeps buffering.

1. QoS is off
2. I've tried stock firmware, merlin and dd-wrt firmwares all with default settings and other varations that 'should' work for best compatibility.
3. I've tried singling it down to a specific band 2.4ghz and 5ghz-1 and 5ghz-2 and the outcome is the same regardless.

The router that it is replacing is an old Buffalo Wireless N and the config worked fine (and still does).

I know that it CAN work because this is the 2nd AC3200 I have had because the first one was returned due to a non working band (which it turns out appears to have been DD-WRT that did that). The previous one had the same issue as this one, except in twiddling with settings at some point I hit the magic combination that made everything work on 5ghz flawlessly.

These devices are all wireless - but that is how it has always been and I can swap out the old router and the new router and the old router works as expected (additionally as I stated above, all these clients have no issues with high speeds to the WAN on the new router).
I am pretty sure this is not a hardware issue, but simply a setting issue. I can't use stock firmware because port forwarding is broken in it so I prefer to use merlin or dd-wrt.

What I do see that I've never really paid attention to before is that on the new router the TX rates are substantially lower than the RX rates. Is this normal? IE: Tx:39 Rx:130 (on low settings on 2.4ghz). On the old router they show as mostly the same IE: Tx:130 Rx:130 or slightly higher than the Rx. Is there a specific setting that might be causing this (I've searched, but haven't had luck on anything specific).

I know it is probably something simple, and I'll keep digging, but waiting for reboots, client reboots, page loads etc on routers is so time consuming...ugh. I've been bashing my head on this a few days now.
 

ImpulsE69

Lifer
Jan 8, 2010
14,946
1,077
126
Update with the solution I think:

I think I have this resolved, but not in the way I expected. I thought that by putting media server and clients on the same band (5ghz-2) I could dedicate that band to the internal streaming and have other clients and gaming on the 2.4 and 5ghz-1, but it seems that having the media server and clients on the same band conflicted with each other for some reason. When I switched the clients to 5ghz-1 and left the server on 5ghz-2 throughput shot up from less than 1% avg to 4-5% avg. I'm not clear as to why except that the server is AC and the clients are N and maybe that had something to do with it. A single 5ghz band surely had enough bandwidth (set to 80) to support at least 1 server and 1 client, so I'm not sure if this is a defect of the router itself, or the clients. I know that in the 2.4 range your speed is capped if you have legacy mode set -- but not really clear if that is the same when talking AC/N.