Ask me about Firefox

Jun 4, 2005
19,723
1
0
Having a problem with Firefox? Looking for some add-on? Post your questions here.

I'll gladly entertain what I can, though I don't know as much as I'd like to, I'll try my best.
 
Jun 4, 2005
19,723
1
0
Originally posted by: Drakkon
how do i get windows update to work within firefox?

? No Support For ActiveX Or Other Microsoft-Proprietary Technologies. ActiveX and other kinds of "active Web content" that have been promoted by Microsoft are major reasons that Internet Explorer has severe security holes ? at least 18 of which currently remain unpatched, according to security consulting firm Secunia. Firefox wisely doesn't allow such content to affect a PC. But this also restricts your use of some Web sites that rely on these technologies, including Windows Update. You can always run Windows Update properly from Windows' Start Menu, but before you run into other ActiveX-only sites, try installing IE View. This is a Firefox extension that allows you to right-click any page you're viewing in a Firefox window and open it instead in an IE window.

I'll continue to hunt google.

EDIT : There's an extension here but it doesn't seem to work with 1.5. Atleast, not for me.
EDIT2 : Well, it seems it does work. It installs then scans for updates on the site itself. I'm not sure if this site is safe, but hey, what can you do? I'll keep hunting.
EDIT3 : After a little bit of digging, it seems that the site is legitimate and effective. I updated a couple drivers aswell.
 

kamper

Diamond Member
Mar 18, 2003
5,513
0
0
Why doesn't ctrl-tab work for cycling between tabs as of 1.5 on os x? How else do I cycle through without the mouse?
 

IlllI

Diamond Member
Feb 12, 2002
4,927
11
81
i've got one.

is there a way to close an open tab by double clicking on it? via plug-in or something else? i've always thought something like that would be useful


 

Atheus

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2005
7,313
2
0
Why does it use so much memory? Why is memory usage reported in the task manager lower than actual usage? Why does memory usage often go up when I close a tab rather than down? Why does it not call free() until I minimise it?

Are you a dev btw?

 

Busie23

Senior member
Jan 24, 2001
640
0
0
How do you open a new tab with whatever is on the current tab, like in IE when you do a new window?
 

Whitecloak

Diamond Member
May 4, 2001
6,074
2
0
Originally posted by: Atheus
Why does it use so much memory? Why is memory usage reported in the task manager lower than actual usage? Why does memory usage often go up when I close a tab rather than down? Why does it not call free() until I minimise it?

Are you a dev btw?

 

secretanchitman

Diamond Member
Apr 11, 2001
9,352
23
91
Originally posted by: Busie23
How do you open a new tab with whatever is on the current tab, like in IE when you do a new window?


ctrl + n for a completely new window
ctrl + t for a new tab


yes, ive also got the memory questions just like atheus posted too.
 
Jun 4, 2005
19,723
1
0
Originally posted by: kamper
Why doesn't ctrl-tab work for cycling between tabs as of 1.5 on os x? How else do I cycle through without the mouse?

Googling for your answer; I have no experience with OS X.

Originally posted by: clandren
is there a way to close an open tab by double clicking on it? via plug-in or something else? i've always thought something like that would be useful

Text. It's for Firefox 1.0 or earlier, but if you use the Nightly Tester Tools Extension, you should be able to use it.

Originally posted by: Atheus
Why does it use so much memory? Why is memory usage reported in the task manager lower than actual usage? Why does memory usage often go up when I close a tab rather than down? Why does it not call free() until I minimise it?

Fx stores in your memory most of the files used to render all the webpages you are visiting. It stores all the images in an uncompressed format, so if you have lots of tabs open, it sure does add up! (I had FF running at 95 mb when I had 25 tabs going) There is a fix for the uncompressed image problem, but it only works in linux.

On top of that it does something called prefetching, where the browser predicts what links you are likely to visit and starts downloading ahead of time in order to speed up page loading. you can disable this feature if you want to.

The third reason for high memory usage is you having too many extensions enabled.

There's a way to reduce the memory usage, though I'm not sure how effective it'll be for you. It should help significantly, though. Text

I'm not entirely sure as to what would cause it to display lower in the Task Manager, I'll hunt for an answer.

If you minimize firefox to the tray or close tabs, the memory is not released. It will keep increasing until you close it.

Originally posted by: Atheus
Are you a dev btw?
No sir.

Originally posted by: Busie23
How do you open a new tab with whatever is on the current tab, like in IE when you do a new window?

Like, a duplicate tab? Text

Originally posted by: JustAnAverageGuy
<obligatory>Why should I use FireFox instead of Opera?</obligatory>

I suppose it's all about preference. Personally, I've used Opera and find it to be rather fast, but not by a noticable amount. I couldn't tell you which is faster without doing any tests.

I remember back when Opera was Shareware; full of ads and a lot of wasted page space. I'd rather support a browser that has always been open-source. I've grown accustomed to Firefox and I feel I can't part with it. The extensions are easy to use and manage, the keyboard shortcuts that are enabled by default are simple, whereas it takes about four keys to open a new tab in Opera.

Again, it's all about preference.
 

Slicedbread

Senior member
Mar 27, 2005
324
0
0
The reason it uses so much memory is because of the fastback feature in 1.5, it stores the pages in memory so it instantly appears when you click back or forward. It stores 5 pages by default so you can see how it can lead to a mess if you visited a site with pictures,flash, and video.


Setting it to 0 should fix it.

 

theMan

Diamond Member
Mar 17, 2005
4,386
0
0
Originally posted by: Drakkon
how do i get windows update to work within firefox?

get an extension called IETab. it allows you to open at tab of IE inside of firefox. it automatically loads IE into a tab when you go to windows update.
 

CTho9305

Elite Member
Jul 26, 2000
9,214
1
81
Originally posted by: kamper
Why doesn't ctrl-tab work for cycling between tabs as of 1.5 on os x? How else do I cycle through without the mouse?

Because apparently it's not normal for OS X apps to use ctrl+tab, so they disabled that feature on OS X.

Originally posted by: clandren
i've got one.

is there a way to close an open tab by double clicking on it? via plug-in or something else? i've always thought something like that would be useful

I'm pretty sure there are multiple extensions that do that. Poke around Mozilla Update for tab-related extensions.

Originally posted by: Atheus
Why does it use so much memory? Why is memory usage reported in the task manager lower than actual usage? Why does memory usage often go up when I close a tab rather than down? Why does it not call free() until I minimise it?
It uses so much memory for one of two reasons 1) you're viewing big pages / pages with lots of images. If so, it has to hold the image data somewhere (memory). 2) It leaks. Developers know it leaks, and are trying to get people to help them track the leaks down (though people seem to prefer to just complain).

The "memory usage" column in task manager is a largely irrelevant number. The one that matters is "VM Size". The "memory usage" goes down when you minimize it because Windows moves programs onto the swapfile and out of RAM when you minimize them. The VM size column won't change when you minimize.

"Memory usage" going up when you close a tab is likely related - if some Firefox code was on the swap file (e.g. the code related to closing documents & tabs), when you make it do something that needs that code, it gets pulled back into RAM, and "memory usage" goes up.

It "calls free()" when it's done with data or when garbage collection is running. The problem is, sometimes it doesn't free data it's done with (leaks, mentioned above).

Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: Atheus
Why does it use so much memory? Why is memory usage reported in the task manager lower than actual usage? Why does memory usage often go up when I close a tab rather than down? Why does it not call free() until I minimise it?
<snip>
On top of that it does something called prefetching, where the browser predicts what links you are likely to visit and starts downloading ahead of time in order to speed up page loading. you can disable this feature if you want to.
That's going to be negligible. Firefox only prefetches links on pages that tell it to prefetch, and VERY few pages out there actually tell it to do prefetching. Also, I think prefetching only downloads the page source (it doesn't turn it into a complete document), so it would only cost as much RAM as is required to hold some HTML + CSS + JS (a few KB).

The third reason for high memory usage is you having too many extensions enabled.
I've heard that explanation, but it's very lacking - a properly-written extension should cost at most a few KB of memory (unless it's doing something very complicated). Now, extensions CAN cause Firefox to leak more if the author isn't very careful. It's pretty easy for an extension to do something that will make Firefox leak.

There's a way to reduce the memory usage, though I'm not sure how effective it'll be for you. It should help significantly, though. Text
That guy is ignoring the performance hit involved in decompressing all the images again when you switch tabs. He should file a bug about his idea though, to get an answer from people more familiar with the code.

I'm not entirely sure as to what would cause it to display lower in the Task Manager, I'll hunt for an answer.
If you disable config.trim_on_minimize, it won't go down (it tells Windows not to do what I mentioned above - Googling that pref name might give you more detail).

Originally posted by: Slicedbread
The reason it uses so much memory is because of the fastback feature in 1.5, it stores the pages in memory so it instantly appears when you click back or forward. It stores 5 pages by default so you can see how it can lead to a mess if you visited a site with pictures,flash, and video.


Setting it to 0 should fix it.
That's not really going to be significant. Fastback shouldn't cost you any more memory than 5 tabs, and if you close Firefox, launch it, check the VM size, open 5 new tabs and check the VM size again, you'll see that it's not a huge amount of memory. Plus, it's a huge slowdown to disable it - I'd take the memory usage any day in exchange for having quick back and forward.

Are you a dev btw?
Yes (though I prefer to work on SeaMonkey)
 
Jun 4, 2005
19,723
1
0
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Are you a dev btw?
Yes

I'm jealous!

New devs are always welcome. If you don't know JS or C++, you can still be useful by doing QA (quality assurance) or bug triaging...

I'm not very knowledgable as you have proven moments ago, I feel I'd just be wasting the teams time. ^^;
 

mechBgon

Super Moderator<br>Elite Member
Oct 31, 1999
30,699
1
0
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: mechBgon
Post your questions here.
When will it be deployable & configurable via Group Policy?

Does this help?
That looks like the right general idea for answering one half of my question (configuration), except I'd like to see Mozilla do the work, not an unknown (to me) third party.

Deployment is the other half. Does Mozilla have a .MSI installer, and a pre-customization tool analogous to IEAK6 that would generate an accompanying transform?
 

igowerf

Diamond Member
Jun 27, 2000
7,697
1
76
Originally posted by: clandren
i've got one.

is there a way to close an open tab by double clicking on it? via plug-in or something else? i've always thought something like that would be useful
Firefox extensions

Search for Tab Clicking Options.
 

CTho9305

Elite Member
Jul 26, 2000
9,214
1
81
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Are you a dev btw?
Yes

I'm jealous!

New devs are always welcome. If you don't know JS or C++, you can still be useful by doing QA (quality assurance) or bug triaging...

I'm not very knowledgable as you have proven moments ago, I feel I'd just be wasting the teams time. ^^;

Do you think I was knowledgable when I started? ;) Everybody starts somewhere. I still don't know nearly as much as a lot of other devs.
 
Jun 4, 2005
19,723
1
0
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Are you a dev btw?
Yes

I'm jealous!

New devs are always welcome. If you don't know JS or C++, you can still be useful by doing QA (quality assurance) or bug triaging...

I'm not very knowledgable as you have proven moments ago, I feel I'd just be wasting the teams time. ^^;

Do you think I was knowledgable when I started? ;) Everybody starts somewhere. I still don't know nearly as much as a lot of other devs.

Well, then. :) How does one become a developer? I'm on the mozillazine forums right now trying to just help out where I can.
 

CTho9305

Elite Member
Jul 26, 2000
9,214
1
81
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Originally posted by: LoKe
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Are you a dev btw?
Yes

I'm jealous!

New devs are always welcome. If you don't know JS or C++, you can still be useful by doing QA (quality assurance) or bug triaging...

I'm not very knowledgable as you have proven moments ago, I feel I'd just be wasting the teams time. ^^;

Do you think I was knowledgable when I started? ;) Everybody starts somewhere. I still don't know nearly as much as a lot of other devs.

Well, then. :) How does one become a developer? I'm on the mozillazine forums right now trying to just help out where I can.

IRC is probably best - irc.mozilla.org, #mozillazine or #firefox or #developers. Say you want to help out, someone can probably get you started on something.