Are These Three Sticks of Samsung 4GB PC3-1600 The Same?

ParatoOptimal

Golden Member
Jan 27, 2004
1,094
2
81
I bought this...
Samsung
4GB 2Rx4 PC3-10600R 9-10-E1-D2
M471B5273CH0-CH9

So,now I need a second stick.

I found this...
Samsung
4GB 2Rx8 PC3-10600R 9-10-F2
M471B5273CH0-CH9 1215

I found this...
Samsung
4GB 2Rx8 PC3-10600S 9-10-F2
M471B5273CH0-CH9 1032

Should I keep looking for an exact match?
Are these all the same RAM or not? Which is a better match for what I've purchased?

Thank you
 
Feb 25, 2011
16,986
1,617
126
I forget why, but 2Rx8 and 2Rx4 is an important distinction - different enough that you might have matching problems in a picky motherboard.

Are they on the compatibility list for your laptop/motherboard?
 

Lordhumungus

Golden Member
Jan 14, 2007
1,207
33
91
I think 2Rx8 vs 2Rx4 is the number of memory modules per side, so it'd be dual rank with 8 chips per side or dual rank with 4 chips per side.

Not 100% on this, but I do know the 2R is dual rank.
 

ParatoOptimal

Golden Member
Jan 27, 2004
1,094
2
81
Yes, it has to do with rank.

I can't find a compatibility list anywhere. I need them for Dell E6410. I have three of them. Two are i5 and one is i7. Dell's chat techs looked up each Service Tag number specific to each laptop to find out the specific needs of each laptop which could have changed over the time they made this model due to whatever parts were available. They all require ONLY PC3-8500 even though anything that uses PC3-8500 should be able to use PC3-10600 and Dell sells ONLY PC3-10600 on it's website as an upgrade for all E6410's. I bought all three laptops used. I think they have the original RAM in them. They all came with 2x2GB PC3-10600.

I'm looking to set them up with 2x4GB PC3-10600. Everything I've read says the only thing to be concerned with is the CAS Latency. It doesn't matter if it's Registered, Non-Registered, ECC or Non-ECC, Buffered or Non-Buffered. There is a difference between server and non-server RAM and between MAC and PC RAM. You don't want Server RAM or MAC RAM for a PC Laptop. I need this for a PC Laptop. It doesn't seem to matter what the CAS Latency is but it should match between the two sticks of RAM.

Nothing I've ever read has stipulated between 2Rx8 and 2Rx4. The numbers after the CL such as "-10-E1-D2" don't matter. I know the 10 is another timing which I would think should always be the lower the better but everything I've read says it doesn't matter. Actually everything I've read says there's little difference between one or two digits of CL but that they should match between the two sticks. I don't know why some have an F2 where as others have E1-D2 as in the above list and two of three above have two different four-digit numbers that the one I bought doesn't have. All three sticks seem to have the same model number.

I'll check each of my three laptops to see if they have 2Rx8 or 2Rx4. I've already bought a stick of 2Rx8,
 

ParatoOptimal

Golden Member
Jan 27, 2004
1,094
2
81
Thanks for everyone's input. Please keep it coming.
I've read that old MACs required more RAM that wouldn't work in a PC laptop. Later current model MAC RAM should work in current PC laptops but I have read of people whose present day MAC RAM would not work in their PC laptop.

I often see MAC RAM selling for less than PC RAM but don't want to risk it not working in my PC laptop.
 
Feb 25, 2011
16,986
1,617
126
Thanks for everyone's input. Please keep it coming.
I've read that old MACs required more RAM that wouldn't work in a PC laptop. Later current model MAC RAM should work in current PC laptops but I have read of people whose present day MAC RAM would not work in their PC laptop.

I often see MAC RAM selling for less than PC RAM but don't want to risk it not working in my PC laptop.

Please stop that. Mac is short for Macintosh. MAC is "media access control" and it's an Ethernet thing.

I also don't know what you're reading, but it's wrong.
 

ParatoOptimal

Golden Member
Jan 27, 2004
1,094
2
81
Sorry, didn't realize the Mac/MAC difference. I've seen Micron Mac RAM with Mac all in caps on the labels. Many people from various sources say it will work on PC but one or two people on tomshardware forums said it didn't work for them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dave_the_nerd
Feb 25, 2011
16,986
1,617
126
Usually when I want to be SURE about RAM compatibility, I'll use Crucial's "memory finder" website to make sure I'm getting stuff that's compatible with my system.

http://www.crucial.com/usa/en/compatible-upgrade-for/Dell/latitude-e6410

They've never steered me wrong - even when the motherboard manufacturer didn't list the Crucial part as compatible, if I order what Crucial says to order, it works. Including RAM for the pickiest of weird old Macs or server motherboards.

You can usually copy/paste the part number into eBay or Amazon to find a slightly better price than what Crucible is offering. But then you don't get the return policy.